Today's Headline Findings — April 28, 2026
Four research deliverables completed today, each closing an open gap from the case research log. Full PDF library →
Framing Principles — How the Case Is Pled
Five rules that govern every memo, exhibit, and filing. Tested against past mistakes; do not violate.
Tools & Document Library
Three live workspaces. Everything else on this page links to specific exhibits or memos within them.
TWO CASE-CHANGING DISCOVERIES — FREEDOM BANK CHAIR & EMAIL-ELIMINATION FRAUD
Methodology upgrade from Tesseract to Apple Vision OCR on April 11 surfaced two findings latent in the evidence corpus. Both are logged as CLAUDE.md Finding #105 and Finding #106. They upgrade the Freedom Bank spoliation track and the email-elimination track from strong inferences to documented affirmative acts.
litman@4patent.com after 7/21/2025 through 12/31/2025 · 334 to r.litman@4patent.com post-7/18 · 171 to rlitman@nathlaw.com post-7/18. Microsoft 365 quarantine notices in the corpus prove the mailboxes were live. Goldberg eliminated ACCESS, not the mailboxes — meaning he could monitor everything.
FREEDOM BANK — UNDISCLOSED TRUST ACCOUNT & SPOLIATION
Newly identified fifth NGM bank account at Freedom Bank — operated as an undisclosed trust account, excluded from the Kren/Schaefer 6/26/2025 report, and closed by transfer on 7/28/2025 exactly one week after Litman filed his federal and state complaints (7/21/2025). This is the likely destination of the $16,202,064.16 erased discrepancy ($32,708,669.08 receipts − $16,506,604.92 paid = Exhibit A gap).
The closure sequence — Litman asks about Freedom Bank (2/9/2024) → Kren/Schaefer report excludes Freedom Bank (6/26/2025) → suits filed (7/21/2025) → account closed by transfer (7/28/2025) — establishes a classic spoliation chronology, converting the $16.2M gap from "missing money" to active concealment and post-litigation destruction of a client trust account. CPA Debbie Schaefer's exclusion of the account from the report she signed raises independent accountant-liability and professional-responsibility issues.
- SUBPOENA Freedom Bank — ALL NGM records, from account opening through 7/28/2025 closure: signature cards, monthly statements, deposit/withdrawal detail, wire logs, closure ticket, and destination of the transferred balance.
- SUBPOENA CPA Debbie Schaefer — working papers, trial balances, client-provided schedules, and all communications with NGM/Goldberg referencing Freedom Bank; plus scope-of-engagement documentation for the 6/26/2025 Kren report.
- DEPOSE Schaefer — her knowledge of Freedom Bank, why it was excluded from Exhibit A / the 6/26/2025 report, who instructed the exclusion, and when she first became aware of the account.
Key Metrics
Litman's Name
Bearing His Name
Signatures
Signatures
Emails (1,598 to JBG)
Searched
Email Hits
Direct Emails
Relevant Emails
(Zero Found)
Litman's Name
to Litman
(2024 / Total)
(593 Clients)
Billings
(WIP)
Damages Range
Interactive damages calculator →
(Contractual + Statutory)
(+ Royalty + Disgorgement)
(+ Punitive + All Categories)
(10 counts, filed 7/22/2025)
($32.7M rec'd – $16.5M paid) — Exhibit A
Demand Letter 7 (7/1/2025 deadline)
(NGM system — Gap #23 closed)
5 Biggest Wins — March 27–28, 2026
Major discoveries from the Gmail deep dive, trust ledger analysis, and arbitration record mining
1. Court Reporter Transcript OBTAINED
Found 120525litman.pdf in Gmail attachments. Judge Maslow's full reasoning on record: Gould (Goldberg's counsel) conceded Count V survives; pierce-the-veil finding re personal liability; court cited Turane v. MGN, LLC, 171 A.D.3d 835 (2d Dep't 2019) for LLC Law § 609 personal participation liability. Previously the single most critical missing document.
2. $32.7M Trust Ledger — View Analysis →
NGM Trust Ledger (534 pages): $32.7M total across 2,214 dockets, 100% Litman-originated work. 95 entries tagged "JBG" (Goldberg personal control). Creates a $16.2M accounting gap vs. $16.5M financial workup — significant unexplained discrepancy pointing to undisclosed revenue.
3. Judicial Estoppel Trap
Goldberg's arbitration position (agreement terminated 6/15/2020) directly contradicts his NY consent defense — he cannot claim consent from an agreement he argued was terminated. His BOP response admits name use was "purely as a courtesy" — destroying the contractual authorization defense.
4. 2,697 USPTO Notification Emails
Found 2,697 USPTO notification emails in the 276K email archive; 1,598 sent to Goldberg personally — each a separate instance of Goldberg receiving and seeing documents bearing Litman's name. Proves continuous actual knowledge. Zero POA discussion found in 51 pages of text messages — name use was entirely unilateral.
5. Goldberg Authenticated POAs Under Oath
Federal Exhibit A (EDNY 1:25-cv-04048): Goldberg authenticated POAs under oath in federal proceedings. He cannot later deny their existence or his signatures. Combined with the "fraud" text (1/30/2023: "if you are on disability, what would be considered legal vs. fraud?") — consciousness of wrongdoing established.
April 10, 2026 — Latest Deliverables
Hashtag Sports letter (July 24 = new latest use), Martha Long origination coding, Nicola Pizza TSDR — plus assignment records, non-consent declaration, NYSCEF completion, accounting forensics, name-use multiplier
Assignment Records, Non-Consent Declaration & NYSCEF Completion
17 Assignment Center records obtained (correspondent transition Litman → Goldberg). Non-consent declaration drafted (52 paragraphs). NYSCEF docket completed through #70. 3 evidence gaps closed.
Hashtag Sports Letter: Latest Confirmed Name Use Pushed to July 24, 2025
NGM letter to Hashtag Sports client signed "Richard C. Litman" dated July 24, 2025 — 6 days AFTER email elimination, 28 days AFTER litigation trigger, 44 days AFTER website removal demand. New latest confirmed use in the entire case. Plus: Martha Long "RCL origination credit" email and Nicola Pizza TSDR record (CN-24396). Full details →
Accounting Forensics & Name-Use Multiplier
KFU $595K trust bypass, KSU $1.4M drained, KISR write-off, 28,870 verified uses, 40,694 Martha emails.
April 2026 Findings (#49–#67)
19 new findings transforming case posture.
Three-Tier Damages Model
$424K floor → $14M+ aspirational ceiling.
NY RPC 1.15 Disciplinary Track
Parallel grievance pressure / 5 per se violations.
21-Month Fee Credit Time Series
20% rule mechanically validated (1.009 mean ratio).
April 1, 2026 — New Findings
iMessage attachment deep dive, case law compendium, BOP filed, and critical evidence updates
Case Law Compendium Built (30+ Cases)
Best case found: Beverley v. Choices Women's Medical Center, 78 N.Y.2d 745 (2d Dep't, affirmed Ct. App. 1991) — doctor's name on a clinic's promotional calendar without consent = § 51 violation as a matter of law. $50K compensatory + $25K punitive. Same department as our case, nearly identical facts but 100x smaller scale.
Also added: Electra v. 59 Murray (consent scope), Waits v. Frito-Lay ($2.6M damages), NY CRL § 50-f (profit disgorgement by analogy), 6 bar ethics opinions on departed attorney names.
6,528 Active Files Under Litman's Name
Internal NGM report (List of Files RL Resp.pdf, 281 pages) shows 6,528 active case files across 593 clients, all with 100% origination credit to Richard Litman. New files still being opened as late as June 2025 — 5 years after termination.
$41.8M Total Billings Confirmed
NGM docket reconciliation spreadsheet (11,633 rows): $41,769,524.80 in total billings. Combined with $32.7M trust ledger, confirms the damages floor far exceeds $18.5M.
KFU Overpayment — Potential Trust Fraud
5 patent search dockets ($500 each expected) had $550,000+ each transferred. Total: $2.76M unexplained, all marked "Uncredited." Supports accounting fraud pattern.
Interim Arbitration Award Obtained
New document (Feb 21, 2023): Arbitrator found Goldberg "unilaterally deposited" Litman's royalties in trust. Called NGM's disability/collateral-source defense "bogus." All claims against Goldberg personally survived.
Tanya Harkins Identity Resolved
Insurance policy Schedule of Attorneys confirms: Tanya Harkins — Associate, hired 03/1999. Not "Tanya Meyer." Gap #9 closed.
Federal Case Briefs Obtained
NGM's full MTD brief (EDNY, Dec 2025): defense strategy revealed — consent via texts, res judicata, "not use in commerce." Goldberg's PI Opposition contains sworn declaration admitting name use was "the parties' practice" for revenue share. Litman's Lanham Act opposition brief also recovered.
BOP Filed by Wachtel Missry (April 1, 2026)
Scott Woller's strategic BOP response: lean, professional, identifies 905 patents + 13 representative examples + 5 categories of non-patent use. Lawyer's strategy: save detailed evidence for MSJ. References "thousands of documents emailed to clients."
Citation Correction: Turane v. MGN, LLC
"Turane v. Kitchens by Katie, Inc." does not exist in any legal database. Corrected across 7 files to the proper citation: Turane v. MGN, LLC, 171 A.D.3d 835 (2d Dep't 2019). Judge Maslow cited it for LLC Law § 609 personal participation liability.
April 4, 2026 — Forensic Trust Account Findings
Deep forensic analysis of trust ledger, AR reports, wire transfers, and invoice records
(Nov 20, 2024)
Invoices ($1.05M)
($559,805)
(No Docket Ref)
($8.9M AR + $1.58M WIP)
Future Entitlement
Trust Account Overdraft — $415,426
November 20, 2024: Trust account went negative by $415,426. Trust accounts are client funds held in escrow — an overdraft means Goldberg was spending client money that didn't exist. This is a potential bar ethics violation independent of the § 51 claim.
133 Smoking Gun Invoices ($1,046,431)
Invoices billed under Litman's name for work performed after 6/15/2020 termination. Each invoice is a separate commercial use of Litman's name directed to a paying client — direct § 51 evidence.
66 Ghost Invoices ($559,805)
Invoices with no corresponding trust deposit or client payment. Either fabricated billing records or evidence of payments diverted outside the trust accounting system.
$8.6M Lump-Sum Sweeps
Large wire transfers swept into the trust account with no docket reference. These cannot be traced to specific client matters — consistent with the commingling pattern that makes per-patent revenue tracing impossible.
Zero-Overlap AR Reports (646 Dockets, $2.46M)
Accounts receivable reports showing 646 dockets totaling $2.46M that do not overlap with the trust ledger. Entirely separate accounting stream — further evidence of the $16.2M gap.
2,833 KFU Dockets (1,917 Unique Inventions)
King Faisal University patent portfolio scale: 2,833 active dockets covering 1,917 unique inventions. All originated by Litman. All still generating revenue under his name.
Greene Letter Deduction Theory (Dec 28, 2022)
Goldberg's accountant (Greene) proposed deducting Litman's share from revenue — evidence of a deliberate scheme to reduce Litman's payments while continuing to use his name for billing.
KFU VP Demand (Dec 2, 2024 — 6 Directives)
KFU Vice President issued 6 specific directives about the patent program. Goldberg never fully answered. Evidence of institutional client dissatisfaction with Goldberg's management of Litman-originated work.
July 2025: 100% of Collections Still Litman-Attributed
As late as July 2025 — five years after termination — 100% of fee collections were still attributed to Richard Litman in NGM's internal records. The name was not just used; it was the entire revenue engine.
KFU Penalties: $314,500 in 2024
King Faisal University imposed $314,500 in penalties in 2024 for missed deadlines and filing errors — work managed by Goldberg under Litman's name. Litman's professional reputation harmed by work quality he had no control over.
Migration Defense Destroyed
PCLaw records from 2018–2022 show the identical lump-sum deposit pattern that appears in the current trust ledger. 1,699 entries across 4+ years. The accounting system changed (PCLaw → current); the pattern of untraceable transfers did not. This eliminates any argument that the irregularities are artifacts of a software migration.
Fee Adjustments: $370K+ Impact
Systematic reduction of Litman's fee base: 20% KFU discount applied across 182 entries, flat fee conversions that cap upside, and $314K in penalties charged back against revenue. All decisions made by Goldberg without Litman's knowledge or consent — each directly reduces Litman's 20% share.
Middle East Statements: $3.01M Outstanding
February 24, 2025 client statements sent to 11 Middle East clients totaling $3.01M across 1,228 invoices. Only 1.5% collected. Litman's 20% share = approximately $602K in future entitlement from this AR alone. All work originated by Litman, all billed under his name.
The Case in Three Elements
NY Civil Rights Law §§ 50-51 requires three elements. Each is supported by documentary evidence — two by Goldberg's own admissions.
Use of Name
Goldberg ADMITS Litman's name appeared on patent front pages and the NGM website after 6/15/2020. (Answer ¶¶ 32, 72)
For Purposes of Trade
$32.7M in trust receipts through Litman-originated accounts; $41.8M in total billings
Firm was 76–100% dependent on Litman-originated work — Goldberg earned only 2.70% of fee credits (June 2025)
Without Written Consent
“Assignee agrees that Assignor owns his name, signature, voice, image, photograph or likeness.”
Signed by Joshua B. Goldberg, Co-Managing Partner
Recorded at USPTO, May 6, 2021 — Reel 007281, Frame 0821
“The assignment of the LITMAN LAW OFFICES, LTD. mark does not include the right to use my name separate and apart from the mark.”
Litman to Goldberg — explicit written notice that name rights were not assigned
View Core Exhibit →Case Timeline
All key dates including Goldberg's 16 personal POA signatures, court actions, and upcoming deadlines. View full analytics →
litman@4patent.com and NathLaw accounts were cut off. NEW 4/11/2026 (Finding #106): Apple Vision OCR + mailbox header sweep proves 8,024+ emails landed in the “eliminated” addresses after this date (7,519 to litman@4patent.com through 12/31/2025; 334 to r.litman@4patent.com; 171 to rlitman@nathlaw.com). Microsoft 365 quarantine notices prove the mailboxes were live. Goldberg eliminated Litman's ACCESS while leaving the mailbox under tenant-admin control — meaning he was in a position to monitor all incoming mail. Upgrades from spoliation to active false statement + Stored Communications Act (18 U.S.C. § 2701) exposure. Also a direct breach of Amendment Section 3 (royalty-free email license). Finding #106 →Affirmative Defense Tracker
Goldberg's 10 affirmative defenses from his Answer (Doc #65) — all anticipated and countered
Failure to State a Cause of Action
Statute of Limitations
Laches
Estoppel
Unclean Hands
Failure to Mitigate
Waiver
Prior Agreement / Contract
No Damages
Consent
Evidence Inventory
Complete evidence corpus gathered and analyzed
Email Analysis Breakdown
276,899 total emails searched — granular breakdown of case-relevant findings
Email Corpus Composition
Post-SOL Email Categories
Key Email Findings
Financial Analysis
Trust ledger deep dive → | Damages calculator →
Generated Under His Name
(WIP Outstanding)
Revenue vs. Litman Payment
Commercial Value of Litman's Name
Post-Arbitration Activity
Monthly count of relevant emails after 6/14/2023 arbitration decision — showing continuous name use
Post-Arbitration Relevant Emails by Month (June 2023 – December 2025)
Post-Arbitration Summary
After the arbitration decision on June 14, 2023, Goldberg continued signing POAs and causing Litman's name to appear on patent filings for at least another 19 months (through January 2025). The email record shows 11,509 case-relevant emails in the post-arbitration period alone, demonstrating that name use was not an isolated incident but a sustained, continuous practice that Goldberg had full knowledge of and control over.
Top 10 Exhibits
Most impactful evidence items for trial and deposition
905-Patent Dataset
Complete list of 905 issued U.S. patents listing Richard C. Litman as attorney since 6/15/2020. Each patent is a separate commercial "publication" under § 51.
Goldberg POA Signature Table
16 Powers of Attorney personally signed by Goldberg (Reg. 44126), each causing Litman's name to appear on the resulting patent. 14 of 16 are post-arbitration.
Dec. 21, 2023 Dual-Action
App 18/392,663: Goldberg signed BOTH the POA and KFU assignment cover sheet on the same day. Proves direct personal involvement in the filing chain.
Nunc Pro Tunc Assignment
Reel 007281, Frame 0821. Goldberg's own recorded USPTO document states Litman owns his name. Destroys the consent defense entirely.
Goldberg's Answer (Doc #65)
Admits Litman's name appeared on patents and website (¶¶32, 72). Denies he "caused" it (¶33) — contradicted by 16 POA signatures.
206-Document Prosecution Chain
Every outgoing USPTO document bearing Litman's name across 21 patents. Each is a separate § 51 "publication." Filing receipts, NOAs, office actions, etc.
Non-Consent Emails (3)
"Not agreed to by me at anytime" and similar explicit non-consent statements from Litman. Out of 276,899 emails searched, zero consent emails exist.
Website Evidence (185 items)
nathlaw.com showed Litman as "PATENT ATTORNEY" through June 21, 2025; "Retired" added ~June 25 (one day before litigation trigger); still listed through Aug 23, 2025 per 176 phone photos. Also: litmanlaw.com — second website using Litman's name.
Clearest POA Signature
App 18/383,448 (Pat. 11,952,371), dated 10/24/2023. "/Joshua B. Goldberg/" and Reg. 44126 are perfectly legible. Best demonstrative for court.
Lafave PTOL-85B Signatures (16)
Issue fee transmittals with printed instruction: "If no name is listed, no name will be printed." Lafave typed Litman's name anyway — 16 separate times.
Research Memos
Key analytical memoranda supporting the case theory
-
Four Categories of Name Use — Master Framework~36,500 acts across 4 categories: USPTO patents, client-facing emails (24,526), trademark practice (1,813), foreseeable republication (9,050+). KNPC control proof. Unified damages multiplier.
-
Deposition Preparation — Goldberg, Long, Kline (147 Questions)Three full outlines with KNPC control proof, Martha solicitation emails, Nicola Pizza trademark chain, and republication knowledge. 14 hours total.
-
SOL Window Acts — 6,700+ Acts Within Statute of LimitationsEvery documented act 7/21/2024–7/21/2025: 16 patents, 190 USPTO docs, 6,476 client-facing emails, 13 trademark acts, 160+ database republications. Martha's emails = client-facing publications.
-
KNPC Transition Control ExhibitAll 3 KNPC patents show Goldberg on Line 74 while billed under "Richard Litman" — proves knowing conscious control over name designation
-
Client-Facing Publication Exhibit24,526 Martha Long emails forwarding Litman-named documents to paying clients + "27 years" solicitation emails
-
Trademark Name Use Exhibit (Nicola Pizza)1,813 trademark emails, 91% CC rate, outside counsel contacting Litman by name, trust ledger under "RL"
-
Foreseeable Republication Exhibit9,050+ third-party database entries (Google Patents, Espacenet, Justia, FPO, Lens.org) — each a separate publication
-
Master Chronological TimelineInteractive timeline with Chart.js visualization. Single reference document for depositions and MSJ preparation. Key stats: 16 POAs, 905 patents, $18.4M revenue.
-
MSJ Evidence ChecklistElements checklist, evidence mapping, defeating all 10 affirmative defenses, damages framework, exhibit index, and remaining gaps. Color-coded readiness indicators.
-
Bill of Particulars — Draft ResponseVerified Bill of Particulars responding to Goldberg's demand (Doc #68). Formal court document format with four-category evidence integration.
-
Deposition Questions for Goldberg40+ questions with exhibit references, organized by topic: POA signatures, financial control, consent, disability awareness
-
Combination Agreement AnalysisNo name-use clause found — agreement never authorized Goldberg to use Litman's name on patent filings
-
Arbitration Enforcement & Damages — Detailed MemoFull legal analysis: arbitration award, Section 51 profits/royalty theories, punitive damages, combined recovery summary
-
Damages Illustration — Visual Breakdown ($11.1M Conservative)Charts and visual breakdown: contractual shortfall, § 51 royalty, punitive, injunctive risk. All from Goldberg's own records.
-
Mechanism of Liability MemoHow Goldberg caused Litman's name to appear: POA → Filing Receipt → Office Action → NOA → Line 74 chain
-
Personal Liability MemoGoldberg's individual (not firm) liability for personal acts: 16 POA signatures, assignment filings
-
Misappropriation Elements ProofElement-by-element analysis of §§ 50-51 claim: name, commercial use, without consent, for trade purposes
-
Email Evidence Memo (Full)276,899 emails analyzed — consent search, financial disputes, POA control directives, and post-arbitration activity
-
Financial Attachment Analysis$18.4M collected under Litman's name, $2.95M shortfall — from Goldberg's own spreadsheets
-
Disability Status TimelineMetLife claim approved Nov 2020; Goldberg knew Litman was disabled while continuing to file under his name
-
Verified Financial Summary (from Goldberg’s spreadsheets)$18.5M in collected fees, quarter-by-quarter and month-by-month, cross-verified against 26 Payment Allocation PDFs
-
KFU & KSU Financial Reconciliation (matter-by-matter)$14.1M in post-SOL collections across 3,132 dockets — 79.3% of all firm revenue from just two clients
-
Goldberg Personal Actions ChronologyComplete timeline of every documented act by Goldberg personally, with source citations
-
POA Goldberg Signature TableAll 19 POAs examined: 16 Goldberg signatures, dates, registration numbers, patent outcomes
-
Combination Agreement — Full TextComplete agreement text with clause-by-clause annotations relevant to the misappropriation claim
-
KNPC Patent Search (resolved — 3 patents, all Goldberg)Zero KNPC patents with Litman on Line 74. All 3 KNPC patents show Goldberg. Gap closed.
-
NGM Federal Opposition (DN 25, EDNY 1:25-cv-04048) — Their Defense PlaybookConnell Foley LLP (Hurley/Gould) opposition filed 10/10/2025. Key claims: Litman consented to Senior Counsel listing, USPTO filings aren't commercial speech, laches, arbitration clause. Exhibit C to DN 25 = text messages (not the Goldberg Declaration, which is a separate sanctions motion filing). CRITICAL: They claim "Plaintiff specifically desired to be listed" — directly rebutted by April 30, 2021 email reserving name rights. Also admits Litman referred 3 clients post-lawsuit — flag for uncle.
Discovery & Deadlines
-
04/02/2026Bills of Particulars due. Both sides. Goldberg's BOP demand response also pending.11 DAYS
-
06/02/2026Depositions complete. All party and non-party depositions must be finished.72 DAYS
-
09/22/2026Compliance conference. CCP Room 282, 9:30am, Judge Gotlieb.184 DAYS
-
02/05/2027Note of Issue. Case must be trial-ready by this date.320 DAYS
URGENT — Freedom Bank Spoliation Track (NEW, 4/11/2026)
- SUBPOENA Freedom Bank — ALL NGM records, account opening through 7/28/2025 closure. Signature cards, monthly statements, deposit/withdrawal detail, wire logs, closure ticket, and destination of the transferred balance.
- SUBPOENA CPA Debbie Schaefer — working papers, trial balances, client-provided schedules, and all communications with NGM/Goldberg about Freedom Bank. Scope-of-engagement documentation for the 6/26/2025 Kren report.
- DEPOSE Schaefer — her knowledge of Freedom Bank, why it was excluded from Exhibit A / the 6/26/2025 report, who instructed the exclusion, and when she first became aware of the account. Consider Schaefer as an adverse witness at MSJ.
- Preserve evidence of the $16,202,064.16 discrepancy as spoliation/adverse inference exhibit. The closure 1 week post-filing converts the gap from "missing money" to active concealment.
Open Items for Counsel
- Court reporter transcript of 12/05/2025 oral decision — OBTAINED 03/27/2026 (
120525litman.pdffrom Gmail). Judge Maslow's reasoning on record; Gould conceded Count V; pierce-the-veil finding; Turane cite. - NYSCEF Docs #62-70 — COMPLETE 04/10/2026. Docs #64, #66, #67, #69 obtained today. Full docket through #70 now in evidence.
- Litman non-consent declaration — DRAFTED 04/10/2026 (52 paragraphs). Ready for counsel review and client signature.
- Assignment PDFs — ALL 17 OBTAINED 04/10/2026. Correspondent transition Litman → Goldberg documented across records.
- Website evidence (Jun 21 – Aug 23, 2025) — EXPANDED 04/10/2026. 9 Wayback captures + 176 nathlaw phone photos. "Retired" added ~June 25 (one day before litigation trigger). litmanlaw.com discovered as second website.
- KNPC pre-2024 patents (Gap #3) — CLOSED 04/10/2026. Zero pre-2024 KNPC patents exist listing Litman.
- $2.4M source document (Gap #23) — CLOSED 04/10/2026. Source identified as the 6/26/2025 Kren report (AAA Lawsuit Package 7-28-25). NGM's own system reconciles to $2,403,125.66. The $2.4M figure is no longer uncle's reconstruction — it is an NGM-system output.
- AAA Lawsuit Package (7-28-25) — INGESTED 04/10/2026. 352 files including federal complaint, Exhibits A–R, demand letters, and arbitration award with direct alter-ego quote. See Section 10 of April 10 findings →.
- ~$214K in unpaid 20% payments (Nov 2024–Feb 2025). Goldberg stopped paying monthly 20% starting November 2024. Four months unpaid: $149,032 + $20,375 + $20,834 + $24,673 = $214,914. See KFU/KSU Reconciliation and Verified Financials.
Quick Links
Damages Calculator
Interactive calculator with client toggles, royalty sliders, punitive multipliers. Three-tier range: $6.1M / $29.1M / $78.4M.
Litigation Analytics
8 interactive visualizations: patent timeline, POA signatures, email volume, financial flows, post-arbitration activity, and more.
Trust Ledger & Goldberg Control
$32.7M trust ledger analysis. 2,214 dockets, 95 JBG-tagged entries, $16.2M accounting gap. Proves financial control over Litman-originated work.
Four Categories of Name Use
~36,500 acts across patents, client emails, trademarks, and databases. KNPC control proof. Damages multiplier framework.
Deposition Prep (147 Questions)
NEW: Three witness outlines (Goldberg 7hr, Long 4hr, Kline 3hr) with KNPC control proof, solicitation emails, and trademark evidence.
SOL Window: 6,700+ Acts
NEW: Every act within the limitations period. 6,476 client-facing emails are the turning point — each one a separate publication.
Forensic Trust Analysis
NEW: Trust overdraft ($415K), 133 smoking gun invoices ($1.05M), 66 ghost invoices ($560K), $8.6M sweeps.
Pipeline & Outstanding ($10.5M)
NEW: $8.9M AR + $1.58M WIP. 646 zero-overlap dockets ($2.46M). 2,833 KFU dockets. 20% entitlement = $2.1M.
Exposure Analysis
NEW: Greene letter deduction theory, KFU VP demand (6 directives), July 2025 100% Litman attribution, $314.5K KFU penalties.
Full Counsel Package
Complete internal briefing with answer analysis, defense counter-evidence, deposition prep, and full evidence index. 458 files.
Settlement Presentation
For the negotiating table. Goldberg's admissions, mechanism of liability, and settlement leverage analysis. 300 files.
206-Document Deck
Per-patent "deck of cards" — every USPTO document bearing Litman's name, each a separate commercial use.
Evidence Explorer
Browse all evidence by category: patents, POAs, assignments, website captures, court filings.
Case Walkthrough
Step-by-step guided tour of the case theory, legal framework, and evidence for any reviewer.
Financial Exhibit
$18.4M revenue analysis from Goldberg's own spreadsheets. Shortfall calculations and client-by-client breakdown.
Evidence Portal Home
Main entry point with links to all dashboards, presentations, and evidence resources.