The Dispositive Document
CORE EXHIBITThe single document that proves all three elements of the §§ 50-51 claim.
No Consent in the Record
Litman objected repeatedly, in writing, over years. Zero consent emails in 276,899 searched.
Exhibit 01
No Consent
No Basis Without My Consent
June 24, 2025
“There is no basis without my consent that I should still be listed on USPTO filings associated with NGM”
Exhibit 02
No Consent
Formal Objection to NGM Lawyer
June 28, 2025
“Your client continued to publicly and professionally present me as Senior Counsel continuously from April 2017 through June 2025, five(5) years after the...”
Exhibit 03
No Consent
I Did Not Agree
July 18, 2023
“Although I did not agree to terminate my affiliation with or wane in my endorsement of and support for NGM over the last three years”
Exhibit 04
No Consent
Not Agreed to by Me
May 01, 2023
“the list of items in your email proposed as a basis for ending the arbitration were not agreed to by me at anytime”
Exhibit 05
No Consent
He Doesn't Work Here Anymore / Gracious Retirement
June 07, 2021
“I have worked here 20 years and this is not Litman. I would have never worked for him and he doesn't work here anymore.”
Goldberg Controlled the Mechanism
He knew how POAs worked. He directed the filings. He signed them personally.
Exhibit 06
POA Control
Goldberg Explains POA Mechanism
January 17, 2023
“Either a withdrawal of our Power of Attorney, or some other document transferring rights back to the inventor, needs to be filed if the inventor wants to...”
Exhibit 07
POA Control
Goldberg Directs POA Post-Arbitration
June 19, 2023
“it is fine to send the POA to the client after the application is filed so the serial number can be included on the POA, then file the POA when we get it back”
Exhibit 09
Third-Party Confirmation
USPTO Examiner: Mr. Litman and Mr. Goldberg
March 01, 2024
“Mr. Litman and Mr. Goldberg, The following proposed Examiner's amendment would place this application in condition for allowance”
Financial Motive
Litman's name generated revenue. Goldberg controlled the money.
Exhibit 08
Financial Motive
I Would Appreciate the Money Due
November 08, 2024
“I would appreciate the money due through October and the reports you have.”
Exhibit 10
Financial Motive
$694K Wire Transfer Dispute
January 09, 2023
“you and Jerry succeed in handling the abundance of opportunity you now have from my practice. The practice is booming”
Financial Analysis
Revenue collected under Litman's name — from Goldberg's own records.