EXHIBIT: USPTO Trademark Emails to rlitman@nathlaw.com

Litman v. Goldberg, Index No. 524343/2025 NY Supreme Court, Kings County -- Hon. Brian L. Gotlieb, J.S.C.

Prepared: March 26, 2026 Source Data: 748 emails from USPTO to rlitman@nathlaw.com Date Range: September 25, 2020 through January 30, 2026

1. Executive Summary

This exhibit documents 748 emails sent by the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) to rlitman@nathlaw.com -- the professional email address of Richard Litman -- across 245 distinct trademark dockets involving 115 identified clients of Nath, Goldberg & Meyer (NGM).

These emails span from September 25, 2020 to January 30, 2026 -- a period of more than five years during which Litman had no involvement with, knowledge of, or control over these trademark matters. Every one of these emails was generated because Litman's name and/or email address remained on file with the USPTO as the attorney of record or correspondence address for these trademark applications and registrations.

Key findings:

748 separate USPTO communications were directed to Litman's professional email address
245 distinct trademark matters across 115 clients continued to list Litman as attorney or correspondent
245 of 245 dockets (100%) also involved Howard Kline (hkline@nathlaw.com), confirming NGM controlled these matters
18 emails also went to Joshua B. Goldberg (jgoldberg@nathlaw.com), proving his awareness
257 emails fall in the post-SOL-safe period (after July 21, 2024)
The most recent email is dated January 30, 2026 -- sent while this lawsuit was actively pending
$203,200.68 in documented payments across 83 trademark dockets that generated emails to Litman

2. Legal Significance Under NY Civil Rights Law Section 51

Each of these 748 emails constitutes a separate "publication" or "use" of Richard Litman's name for commercial purposes under New York Civil Rights Law Section 51:

The Name: Each email is addressed to "rlitman@nathlaw.com" or includes "Richard Litman" as a named recipient. The USPTO sends these emails to the attorney of record -- meaning Litman's name was on file with the federal government as the responsible attorney for each matter.
Commercial Purpose: These trademark matters are revenue-generating legal work for NGM. The firm billed clients for these matters and collected fees (at least $203,200.68 documented in the cross-referenced payment data). Litman's name on the filings gave NGM the appearance of continuity and the benefit of his professional reputation.
Without Consent: Litman did not authorize the continued use of his name on these matters after his departure. He had no knowledge that USPTO communications were being sent to his email address for matters he was not handling.
Defendant's Control: Howard Kline (an NGM employee) is a co-recipient on 702 of 748 emails (93%), confirming that NGM staff controlled these filings. Goldberg himself appears on 18 emails for matters he was directly involved in. At any point, Goldberg or Kline could have updated the attorney of record to remove Litman's name -- they chose not to.
Each Email Is a Separate Use: Under the "deck of cards" theory, each USPTO email represents a distinct act of using Litman's name in a commercial context. The USPTO's own system treated Litman as the attorney of record and directed official government correspondence to him accordingly.

3. The July 2025 Section 8/15 Filing -- Filed Using Litman's Credentials

On July 2, 2025, the USPTO sent an email solely to rlitman@nathlaw.com (no other recipients) confirming receipt of a Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability Under Sections 8 and 15 for Registration Number 5804556 (Docket 6217.50).

Field	Value
Date	July 2, 2025
From	teas@uspto.gov
To	rlitman@nathlaw.com
CC	(none)
Subject	6217.50 Registration Number 5804556: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability Under Sections 8 and 15
Litman Position	TO (sole recipient)
Docket	6217.50 (Nicola Pizza trademark portfolio)

This is significant for several reasons:

A Section 8/15 Declaration is a substantive legal filing -- it is a sworn statement that a trademark is still in use in commerce. Filing such a declaration under an attorney's credentials without authorization is a serious matter.
The confirmation went only to rlitman@nathlaw.com -- not to Kline, not to docketing, not to anyone else. This means the filing was submitted using Litman's credentials as the attorney of record.
This occurred after the complaint in this case was filed, demonstrating continued unauthorized use of Litman's name even during active litigation over that very issue.
Docket 6217 is the Nicola Pizza portfolio -- a long-standing Litman client. The use of Litman's name on this filing traded on his decades-long relationship with this client.

Additional Section 8/9/15 Filings Using Litman's Credentials

The July 2, 2025 filing was not isolated. Multiple Section 8, 9, and 15 declarations were filed through Litman's credentials:

2025-07-02: 6217.50 Registration Number 5804556: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 6217.50 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2025-06-10: 7781.09 Registration Number 4755797: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 7781.09 (Predator Racing Inc.)
2025-05-23: 32999.16 Registration Number 6054606: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 32999.16 (Law Office of Bart S. Fisher)
2025-05-23: 32999.15 Registration Number 6054605: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 32999.15 (Law Office of Bart S. Fisher)
2025-03-31: 32380.22 Registration Number 5780021: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 32380.22 (Superior Products International II, Inc.)
2025-02-27: 32662.00 Registration Number 4697459: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 32662.00 (Active8Social, LLC)
2025-01-08: 32752.02 Registration Number 5656135: Received Your Declaration of Use of Mark in Commerce Under Sec -- Docket 32752.02 (FRS GmbH & Co. KG)
2025-01-07: 10788.05 Registration Number 5856511: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 10788.05 (Heartland Catfish Company, Inc.)
2025-01-03: 6217.49 Registration Number 5804562: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 6217.49 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2025-01-03: 6217.38 Registration Number 3037403: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 6217.38 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2025-01-03: 6217.28 Registration Number 1352205: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 6217.28 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2025-01-03: 6217.31 Registration Number 1891261: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 6217.31 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2024-12-23: 32646.06 Registration Number 5636116: Received Your Declaration of Use of Mark in Commerce Under Sec -- Docket 32646.06 (Julia and Josephine, LLC)
2024-12-18: 32818.00 Registration Number 5938331: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 32818.00 (Capital Second Investments, LLC)
2024-12-04: 30449.02 Registration Number 5928251: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 30449.02 (National Association of Nutrition Professionals)
2024-12-04: 29682.03 Registration Number 5626473: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 29682.03 (Federal Hill Mortgage Company, LLC)
2024-12-01: 32980.01 Registration Number 5629736: Received Your Declaration of Use of Mark in Commerce Under Sec -- Docket 32980.01 (Briscoe, James Dana)
2024-11-04: 32996.01 Registration Number 5600804: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 32996.01 (Discover Science 4 Kids, LLC)
2024-08-22: 2414.68 Registration Number 2816356: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 2414.68 (Birch Horton Bittner and Cherot)
2024-08-09: 28639.01 Registration Number 4480845: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 28639.01 (Barnes, Mark)
2024-07-31: 32999.01 Registration Number 5554628: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 32999.01 (3-A Sanitary Standards Inc.)
2024-07-29: 32380.19 Registration Number 5638824: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 32380.19 (Superior Products International II, Inc.)
2024-06-21: 1389.01 Registration Number 5756395: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 1389.01 (Faswell Corporation)
2024-06-04: 15085.28 Registration Number 4680160: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 15085.28 (Becker, Theodore J.)
2024-05-13: 22307.00 Registration Number 2850630: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 22307.00 (NILS, INC.)
2024-05-08: 0525.32 Registration Number 1835221: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 0525.32 (unknown client)
2024-04-29: 2414.69 Registration Number 2808045: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 2414.69 (Birch Horton Bittner and Cherot)
2024-04-29: 2414.67 Registration Number 2868082: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 2414.67 (Birch Horton Bittner and Cherot)
2024-04-16: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5330662: MO -- Docket 11939.02 (McCoy, LaTina D.)
2024-04-11: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2722807: Miscell -- Docket 12616.20 (Galavis Hernandez, Ricardo)
2024-04-03: 32825.01 Registration Number 5453006: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 32825.01 (ERISYS LLC)
2024-04-02: 22795.00 Registration Number 2861742: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 22795.00 (Kuhns, Duane H.)
2024-03-13: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 1798021: NIC SPI -- Docket 6217.15 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2024-03-07: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2768446: Miscell -- Docket 12616.36 (Servicios Corporativos de Administracion G.M.Z., S.A. de C.V.)
2024-03-02: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 1792810: MAMA NI -- Docket 6217.30 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2024-03-01: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2838118: ISAAC H -- Docket 22586.00 (Isaac Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.)
2024-02-23: 32542.00 Registration Number 4487438: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 32542.00 (Adams, Amy)
2024-02-21: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2769782: ONE DRO -- Docket 12616.10 (Servicios Corporativos de Administracion G.M.Z., S.A. de C.V.)
2024-02-21: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2756960: ONE DRO -- Docket 12616.08 (Servicios Corporativos de Administracion G.M.Z., S.A. de C.V.)
2024-02-16: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2818152: CR CORP -- Docket 20888.00 (CORPORATE RENTALS, LLC)
2024-02-04: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 4386518: KONEKTE -- Docket 32442.00 (Konekte Manufacturas S.A. de C.V.)
2024-01-23: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance Section 8: U.S. Trademark RN 5373830: GROUNDED AERIAL: Docket/Re -- Docket 32994.00 (XYANDZ LLC)
2024-01-18: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5279284: SH -- Docket 24159.03 (Schaller Corporation)
2024-01-13: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2742853: PROWLER -- Docket 7781.06 (Predator Racing Inc.)
2024-01-11: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5249973: NI -- Docket 6217.46 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2024-01-04: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 4367645: SPOTCIT -- Docket 32449.01 (Spotcity Cupcakes, LLC)
2023-12-01: 12616.20 Registration Number 2722807: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 12616.20 (Galavis Hernandez, Ricardo)
2023-11-29: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 1775381: NICOLA' -- Docket 6217.14 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2023-11-17: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 4521638: SOAP LI -- Docket 20365.03 (Sea Lark Enterprises, Inc.)
2023-11-10: 32994.00 Registration Number 5373830: Received Your Declaration of Use of Mark in Commerce Under Sec -- Docket 32994.00 (XYANDZ LLC)
2023-10-30: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance Section 8: U.S. Trademark RN 5230531: FRS: Docket/Reference No. -- Docket 32752.00 (FRS GmbH & Co. KG)
2023-10-25: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5309587: WH -- Docket 31964.03 (Isaac Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.)
2023-10-18: 11939.02 Registration Number 5330662: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 11939.02 (McCoy, LaTina D.)
2023-10-04: 6217.15 Registration Number 1798021: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 6217.15 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2023-10-01: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 4353568: EARTHWA -- Docket 32712.01 (Earthwalk Communications, Inc.)
2023-09-29: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2818209: MAC RAK -- Docket 19197.01 (Mac Rak, Inc.)
2023-09-27: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2625718: INSTANT -- Docket 12616.02 (Galavis Hernandez, Ricardo)
2023-09-27: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2625717: INSTANT -- Docket 12616.03 (Galavis Hernandez, Ricardo)
2023-09-23: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5426570: SA -- Docket 21887.10 (EZ Web Industries, Inc.)
2023-09-23: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5416326: MS -- Docket 21887.09 (Ms. Carita Safetruck, Inc.)
2023-09-22: 12616.36 Registration Number 2768446: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 12616.36 (Servicios Corporativos de Administracion G.M.Z., S.A. de C.V.)
2023-09-13: 6217.30 Registration Number 1792810: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 6217.30 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2023-09-11: 22586.00 Registration Number 2838118: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 22586.00 (Isaac Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.)
2023-09-05: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance Section 8: U.S. Trademark RN 5183720: FAST RELIABLE SEAWAYS: Doc -- Docket 32752.03 (FRS GmbH & Co. KG)
2023-08-28: 12616.10 Registration Number 2769782: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 12616.10 (Servicios Corporativos de Administracion G.M.Z., S.A. de C.V.)
2023-08-25: 12616.08 Registration Number 2756960: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 12616.08 (Servicios Corporativos de Administracion G.M.Z., S.A. de C.V.)
2023-08-22: 20888.00 Registration Number 2818152: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 20888.00 (CORPORATE RENTALS, LLC)
2023-08-08: 32442.00 Registration Number 4386518: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 32442.00 (Konekte Manufacturas S.A. de C.V.)
2023-08-07: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 4299088: COOL DO -- Docket 29943.06 (Davey (Valencia), Michelle)
2023-08-07: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 4328731: CUSTOMA -- Docket 29943.05 (Davey (Valencia), Michelle)
2023-07-25: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5385400: MS -- Docket 21887.08 (Ms. Carita, Inc.)
2023-07-20: 24159.03 Registration Number 5279284: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 24159.03 (Schaller Corporation)
2023-07-17: 6217.46 Registration Number 5249973: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 6217.46 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2023-07-17: 7781.06 Registration Number 2742853: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 7781.06 (Predator Racing Inc.)
2023-07-09: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 4413433: ESTETIQ -- Docket 32520.04 (Estetique Inc. USA)
2023-07-07: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 4446372: REJUVEM -- Docket 32520.03 (Estetique Inc. USA)
2023-07-07: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5129068: DA -- Docket 32825.00 (ERISYS LLC)
2023-07-07: 32449.01 Registration Number 4367645: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 32449.01 (Spotcity Cupcakes, LLC)
2023-07-06: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 4261699: RE-CRET -- Docket 31241.03 (Enviro-Cycle, LLC)
2023-06-27: 32752.00 Registration Number 5230531: Received Your Declaration of Use of Mark in Commerce Under Sec -- Docket 32752.00 (FRS GmbH & Co. KG)
2023-06-14: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 1744170: SUPER T -- Docket 3754.02 (Superior Products International II, Inc.)
2023-06-07: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5144548: AL -- Docket 2414.79 (Alaska SeaLife Center)
2023-06-02: 6217.14 Registration Number 1775381: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 6217.14 (Nicola Pizza, Inc.)
2023-04-25: 31964.03 Registration Number 5309587: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 31964.03 (Isaac Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.)
2023-04-17: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 4229662: COPYCAD -- Docket 31320.03 (Escalera, Inc.)
2023-04-07: 32752.03 Registration Number 5183720: Received Your Declaration of Use of Mark in Commerce Under Sec -- Docket 32752.03 (FRS GmbH & Co. KG)
2023-03-29: 32712.01 Registration Number 4353568: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 32712.01 (Earthwalk Communications, Inc.)
2023-03-27: 19197.01 Registration Number 2818209: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 19197.01 (Mac Rak, Inc.)
2023-03-23: 12616.03 Registration Number 2625717: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 12616.03 (Galavis Hernandez, Ricardo)
2023-03-23: 12616.02 Registration Number 2625718: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 12616.02 (Galavis Hernandez, Ricardo)
2023-03-22: 21887.10 Registration Number 5426570: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 21887.10 (EZ Web Industries, Inc.)
2023-03-22: 21887.09 Registration Number 5416326: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 21887.09 (Ms. Carita Safetruck, Inc.)
2023-03-07: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5112828: DU -- Docket 32201.02 (4 Aces Import, Inc.)
2023-02-25: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2687192: INTREXD -- Docket 18805.00 (Papelino, Jeannine)
2023-02-25: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2687191: INTRE X -- Docket 18805.01 (Papelino, Jeannine)
2023-02-09: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5203053: 4A -- Docket 32201.03 (Rupani, Arman)
2023-01-27: 21887.08 Registration Number 5385400: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 21887.08 (Ms. Carita, Inc.)
2023-01-21: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance/Acknowledgement Sections 8 and 15: U.S. Trademark RN 5189919: 3A -- Docket 32999.11 (3-A Sanitary Standards Inc.)
2023-01-19: 29943.06 Registration Number 4299088: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 29943.06 (Davey (Valencia), Michelle)
2023-01-19: 29943.05 Registration Number 4328731: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 29943.05 (Davey (Valencia), Michelle)
2023-01-12: 32825.00 Registration Number 5129068: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 32825.00 (ERISYS LLC)
2023-01-06: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance Section 8: U.S. Trademark RN 5008819: PROTECTION PILLOW (Stylize -- Docket 32646.01 (Schaich Bricken, Stephanie)
2022-12-16: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance and Renewal Sections 8 and 9: U.S. Trademark RN 2591508: NORTHER -- Docket 15985.03 (Rinio, Earl)
2022-12-14: 32520.04 Registration Number 4413433: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 32520.04 (Estetique Inc. USA)
2022-12-12: 31241.03 Registration Number 4261699: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under S -- Docket 31241.03 (Enviro-Cycle, LLC)
2022-12-01: 2414.79 Registration Number 5144548: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 2414.79 (Alaska SeaLife Center)
2022-11-17: 3754.02 Registration Number 1744170: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Renewal under Se -- Docket 3754.02 (Superior Products International II, Inc.)
2022-02-15: Official USPTO Notice of Acceptance Section 8: U.S. Trademark RN 4697459: HASHTAG SPORTS: Docket/Ref -- Docket 32662.00 (Active8Social, LLC)
2020-10-07: 33049.02 Registration number 4827756: Received Your Combined Declaration of Use and Incontestability -- Docket 33049.02 (Group SVM Inc.)

4. Year-by-Year Breakdown

Year	Email Count	Percentage	Notable Events
2020	3	0.4%	SOL cutoff (6/15/2020); earliest emails in dataset
2021	4	0.5%	Minimal USPTO activity captured
2022	33	4.4%	Increased trademark maintenance filings
2023	193	25.8%	Post-arbitration (6/14/2023); significant activity
2024	341	45.6%	Peak year -- highest volume; lawsuit preparation period
2025	169	22.6%	Lawsuit filed; activity continues unabated through December
2026	5	0.7%	Emails continue during active litigation through January 30
TOTAL	748	100%

5. 2026 Emails -- All Listed in Full (Most Recent Evidence)

These emails were sent while Litman v. Goldberg was actively pending before the court. Each one demonstrates that Goldberg and NGM continued to use Litman's name on trademark matters even after being sued for doing so.

Email 1: 2026-01-30

Field	Value
Date	2026-01-30
From	tmofficialnotices@uspto.gov
To	hkline@nathlaw.com; rlitman@nathlaw.com; docketing@nathlaw.com; efile@4patent.com
Subject	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 78798341 -- Docket/Reference No. 2743.01
Litman Position	TO
Docket	2743.01
Serial Number	78798341

Email 2: 2026-01-26

Field	Value
Date	2026-01-26
From	tmofficialnotices@uspto.gov
To	hkline@nathlaw.com; rlitman@nathlaw.com; docketing@nathlaw.com; efile@4patent.com; vicki@kidscoop.com
Subject	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 90011056 -- Docket/Reference No. 18654.01
Litman Position	TO
Docket	18654.01
Serial Number	90011056
Client	Whiting, Vicki

Email 3: 2026-01-24

Field	Value
Date	2026-01-24
From	tmofficialnotices@uspto.gov
To	hkline@nathlaw.com; rlitman@nathlaw.com; docketing@nathlaw.com; efile@4patent.com; dave.erisman@erisys.com
Subject	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 87082316 -- Docket/Reference No. 32825.00
Litman Position	TO
Docket	32825.00
Serial Number	87082316
Client	ERISYS LLC

Email 4: 2026-01-12

Field	Value
Date	2026-01-12
From	tmofficialnotices@uspto.gov
To	hkline@nathlaw.com; rlitman@nathlaw.com; docketing@nathlaw.com; efile@4patent.com; pkassel@healthysole.com
Subject	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 88949417 -- Docket/Reference No. 32720.20
Litman Position	TO
Docket	32720.20
Serial Number	88949417
Client	Healthy Sole, LLC

Email 5: 2026-01-05

Field	Value
Date	2026-01-05
From	tmofficialnotices@uspto.gov
To	hkline@nathlaw.com; rlitman@nathlaw.com; docketing@nathlaw.com; efile@4patent.com; pkassel@healthysole.com
Subject	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 88949422 -- Docket/Reference No. 32720.21
Litman Position	TO
Docket	32720.21
Serial Number	88949422
Client	Kassel, Robert

6. 2025 Emails -- Complete List (169 Emails)

Listed in reverse chronological order.

#	Date	Docket	Serial No.	Client	Position	Goldberg
1	2025-12-30	32201.21T	99247515	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
2	2025-12-24	32201.21T	99247515	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
3	2025-12-22	11939.06	88933561	Baby 7 LLC	TO	No
4	2025-12-15	33052.00	88681904	The First Baptist Church of Mi...	TO	No
5	2025-11-26	32201.21T	99247515	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
6	2025-11-21	25713.05	76629333	William Harmeyer & Associates	TO	No
7	2025-11-17	32201.20T	99247507	4 Aces Import, Inc.	CC	No
8	2025-11-17	32201.19T	99247500	4 Aces Import, Inc.	CC	No
9	2025-11-17	32201.21T	99247515	4 Aces Import, Inc.	CC	No
10	2025-11-17	32201.18T	99247493	4 Aces Import, Inc.	CC	No
11	2025-11-17	32201.17T	99247490	4 Aces Import, Inc.	CC	No
12	2025-11-04	32999.16	88369139	Law Office of Bart S. Fisher	TO	No
13	2025-11-01	32520.05	86939134	Estetique Inc. USA	TO	No
14	2025-10-30	6217.50	88205019	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
15	2025-10-29	32201.21T	99247515	4 Aces Import, Inc.	CC	No
16	2025-10-21	200911.05T	99034636	BHC Management, LLC	TO	YES
17	2025-10-20	200911.06T	99034640	BHC Management, LLC	TO	YES
18	2025-10-14	N/A	99441606		CC	No
19	2025-10-13	33003.01	88850407	Styles Fitness and Wellness, L...	TO	No
20	2025-10-08	31679.02T	97515161	Yuftczak, William	TO	No
21	2025-10-07	21887.21T	98858258	EZ Web Industries, Inc.	TO	No
22	2025-10-06	15985.04	88822732	Alaska Game Bags, Inc.	TO	No
23	2025-10-03	7781.09	86437094	Predator Racing Inc.	TO	No
24	2025-10-03	32999.15	88369134	Law Office of Bart S. Fisher	TO	No
25	2025-09-22	32825.09T	98966666	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
26	2025-09-15	32833.03	88698961	Alhuraibi, Shayma S J M	TO	No
27	2025-08-26	32825.06T	98378256	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
28	2025-08-26	200911.06T	99034640	BHC Management, LLC	TO	YES
29	2025-08-26	200911.05T	99034636	BHC Management, LLC	TO	YES
30	2025-08-20	200911.06T	99034640	BHC Management, LLC	TO	YES
31	2025-08-20	200911.05T	99034636	BHC Management, LLC	TO	YES
32	2025-08-19	21887.21T	98858258	EZ Web Industries, Inc.	TO	No
33	2025-08-13	21887.21T	98858258	EZ Web Industries, Inc.	TO	No
34	2025-08-09	200718.00T	98105178	Texas Coble, Ltd.	TO	No
35	2025-08-04	32380.22	88174665	Superior Products Internationa...	TO	No
36	2025-07-30	6217.51T	98499741	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
37	2025-07-29	6217.51T	98499741	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
38	2025-07-29	32825.09T	98966666	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
39	2025-07-26	32646.01	86511315	Schaich Bricken, Stephanie	TO	No
40	2025-07-24	32662.00	86260943	Active8Social, LLC	TO	No
41	2025-07-23	32825.09T	98966666	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
42	2025-07-21	N/A	99034640		CC	YES
43	2025-07-21	N/A	99034644		CC	YES
44	2025-07-11	200340.00T	97028221	Zenobia International Investme...	TO	No
45	2025-07-09	200911.06T	99034640	BHC Management, LLC	CC	YES
46	2025-07-02	6217.50	N/A	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
47	2025-06-24	32825.05T	98378248	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
48	2025-06-23	N/A	99247515		CC	No
49	2025-06-23	N/A	99247507		CC	No
50	2025-06-23	N/A	99247500		CC	No
51	2025-06-23	N/A	99247493		CC	No
52	2025-06-23	N/A	99247490		CC	No
53	2025-06-23	33051.00	88622953		TO	No
54	2025-06-23	32471.02	88605906	Well Marriage Center, LLC	TO	No
55	2025-06-18	21887.21T	98858258	EZ Web Industries, Inc.	TO	No
56	2025-06-11	200713.01T	98677594	ScansX for Experimental Resear...	CC	No
57	2025-06-11	6217.31	74503222	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
58	2025-06-11	6217.28	73502100	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
59	2025-06-11	6217.38	76619762	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
60	2025-06-11	N/A	97212557		CC	No
61	2025-06-10	7781.09	N/A	Predator Racing Inc.	TO	No
62	2025-06-10	32825.06T	98378256	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
63	2025-06-04	32825.06T	98378256	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
64	2025-05-28	32999.12	74627816	3-A Sanitary Standards Inc.	TO	No
65	2025-05-23	32999.16	N/A	Law Office of Bart S. Fisher	TO	No
66	2025-05-23	32999.15	N/A	Law Office of Bart S. Fisher	TO	No
67	2025-05-20	32752.02	86959530	FRS GmbH & Co. KG	TO	No
68	2025-05-20	32224.02T	98165120	Moppie 31 LLC	TO	No
69	2025-05-20	32224.03T	98165158	Moppie 31 LLC	TO	No
70	2025-05-20	32201.09T	98604120	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
71	2025-05-20	32201.10T	98604132	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
72	2025-05-13	32646.06	87687797	Julia and Josephine, LLC	TO	No
73	2025-05-12	32999.15	88369134	Law Office of Bart S. Fisher	TO	No
74	2025-05-12	32999.16	88369139	Law Office of Bart S. Fisher	TO	No
75	2025-05-06	21887.21T	98858258	EZ Web Industries, Inc.	CC	No
76	2025-05-06	32825.05T	98378248	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
77	2025-05-05	32980.01	87759964	Briscoe, James Dana	TO	No
78	2025-04-30	32825.05T	98378248	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
79	2025-04-29	32224.03T	98165158	Moppie 31 LLC	TO	No
80	2025-04-29	32224.02T	98165120	Moppie 31 LLC	TO	No
81	2025-04-29	32201.11T	98604138	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
82	2025-04-29	32201.12T	98604146	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
83	2025-04-29	28430.50T	98594826	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	TO	No
84	2025-04-28	16725.03	88445697	James Hurysz and Helena Zinkha...	TO	No
85	2025-04-18	21887.21T	98858258	EZ Web Industries, Inc.	CC	No
86	2025-04-17	10788.05	88309842	Heartland Catfish Company, Inc...	TO	No
87	2025-04-16	6217.49	88205155	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
88	2025-04-15	28430.49T	98593436	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	TO	No
89	2025-04-07	32825.06T	98378256	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
90	2025-04-07	32825.06T	98378256	ERISYS LLC	CC	No
91	2025-04-07	33003.00	87859312	Styles Fitness and Wellness, L...	TO	No
92	2025-04-07	21887.17	88593878	Ms. Carita, Inc.	TO	No
93	2025-04-03	32818.00	87062905	Capital Second Investments, LL...	TO	No
94	2025-04-03	26363.06T	97369824	Champion, Mark E.	TO	No
95	2025-04-02	26363.06T	97369824	Champion, Mark E.	TO	No
96	2025-04-01	32201.09T	98604120	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
97	2025-04-01	32201.10T	98604132	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
98	2025-03-31	32380.22	N/A	Superior Products Internationa...	TO	No
99	2025-03-31	31964.06	88599483	Isaac Heating & Air Conditioni...	TO	No
100	2025-03-31	31964.05	88599475	Isaac Heating & Air Conditioni...	TO	No
101	2025-03-26	32201.09T	98604120	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
102	2025-03-26	32201.10T	98604132	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
103	2025-03-25	30449.02	88158043	National Association of Nutrit...	TO	No
104	2025-03-24	29682.03	87876035	Federal Hill Mortgage Company,...	TO	No
105	2025-03-24	21887.14	88593859	Ms. Carita Safetruck, Inc.	TO	No
106	2025-03-24	21887.15	88593864	Ms. Carita Safetruck, Inc.	TO	No
107	2025-03-24	21887.16	88593873	Ms. Carita Safetruck, Inc.	TO	No
108	2025-03-24	21887.18	88593880	Ms. Carita, Inc.	TO	No
109	2025-03-19	00340.00T	97028221		TO	No
110	2025-03-18	32201.14T	98604156	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
111	2025-03-18	32201.13T	98604150	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
112	2025-03-17	28430.49T	98593436	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	CC	No
113	2025-03-13	00400.00T	97212557		TO	No
114	2025-03-11	32825.07T	98378261	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
115	2025-03-11	28430.50T	98594826	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	TO	No
116	2025-03-10	28430.51T	98595246	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	TO	No
117	2025-03-10	33039.00	88505211	Drishti Beats, LLC	TO	No
118	2025-03-06	32996.01	87850041	Discover Science 4 Kids, LLC	TO	No
119	2025-03-06	32201.10T	98604132	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
120	2025-03-06	32201.09T	98604120	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
121	2025-03-05	28430.50T	98594826	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	TO	No
122	2025-02-27	32825.05T	98378248	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
123	2025-02-27	32825.06T	98378256	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
124	2025-02-27	28430.49T	98593436	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	CC	No
125	2025-02-27	32662.00	N/A	Active8Social, LLC	TO	No
126	2025-02-20	200718.00T	98105178	Texas Coble, Ltd.	TO	No
127	2025-02-20	00718.00T	98105178		TO	No
128	2025-02-19	N/A	98677594		CC	No
129	2025-02-18	33040.00	88497267		TO	No
130	2025-02-17	200713.01T	98677594	ScansX for Experimental Resear...	CC	No
131	2025-02-12	32224.02T	98165120	Moppie 31 LLC	TO	No
132	2025-02-12	32224.03T	98165158	Moppie 31 LLC	TO	No
133	2025-02-12	N/A	N/A		TO	No
134	2025-02-12	N/A	N/A		TO	No
135	2025-02-10	N/A	N/A		TO	No
136	2025-02-10	N/A	99034644		CC	YES
137	2025-02-10	N/A	99034640		CC	YES
138	2025-02-10	N/A	99034636		CC	YES
139	2025-02-07	N/A	N/A		TO	No
140	2025-02-03	6217.51T	98499741	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
141	2025-01-30	28430.50T	98594826	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	TO	No
142	2025-01-30	28430.49T	98593436	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	TO	No
143	2025-01-28	32201.11T	98604138	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
144	2025-01-28	32201.12T	98604146	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
145	2025-01-28	32201.14T	98604156	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
146	2025-01-28	32201.13T	98604150	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
147	2025-01-22	32201.11T	98604138	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
148	2025-01-22	32201.12T	98604146	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
149	2025-01-22	32201.14T	98604156	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
150	2025-01-22	32201.13T	98604150	4 Aces Import, Inc.	TO	No
151	2025-01-21	32825.07T	98378261	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
152	2025-01-15	32825.09T	98966666	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
153	2025-01-15	32825.07T	98378261	ERISYS LLC	TO	No
154	2025-01-14	12708.06T	97917724	Power Box Inc.	TO	No
155	2025-01-14	28430.51T	98595246	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	TO	No
156	2025-01-11	32825.05T	98378248	ERISYS LLC	CC	No
157	2025-01-08	32201.10T	98604132	4 Aces Import, Inc.	CC	No
158	2025-01-08	32201.09T	98604120	4 Aces Import, Inc.	CC	No
159	2025-01-08	32752.02	N/A	FRS GmbH & Co. KG	TO	No
160	2025-01-08	28430.51T	98595246	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	TO	No
161	2025-01-07	32201.12T	98604146	4 Aces Import, Inc.	CC	No
162	2025-01-07	32201.14T	98604156	4 Aces Import, Inc.	CC	No
163	2025-01-07	10788.05	N/A	Heartland Catfish Company, Inc...	TO	No
164	2025-01-06	28430.49T	98593436	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	CC	No
165	2025-01-06	28430.50T	98594826	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	CC	No
166	2025-01-03	6217.49	N/A	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
167	2025-01-03	6217.38	N/A	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
168	2025-01-03	6217.28	N/A	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No
169	2025-01-03	6217.31	N/A	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	TO	No

7. Complete Docket-Client Map

All 245 unique trademark dockets that generated USPTO emails to rlitman@nathlaw.com, sorted by email count.

Docket	Client	Serial No.	Mark	Emails	First	Last	Kline	Goldberg	Paid
26363.06T	Champion, Mark E.	97369824	DRIVEN REELS FROM TH..	13	2023-02-08	2025-04-03	Y		$3,920
29920.17T	Hershey’s Metal Meister, LLC	97767250	Halo and Design	11	2023-01-25	2024-10-29	Y		$2,920
32825.06T	ERISYS LLC	98378256	ERISYS	10	2024-01-26	2025-08-26	Y		$6,610
31679.02T	Yuftczak, William	97515161	HAPPY TRAILS	9	2023-05-24	2025-10-08	Y		$1,222
6217.51T	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	98499741	TASTE OF THE 1ST STA..	9	2024-04-15	2025-07-30	Y		$3,300
12708.06T	Power Box Inc.	97917724	POWER BOX	9	2023-05-02	2025-01-14	Y
32201.07T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	98027416		9	2023-06-05	2024-10-22	Y		$3,740
32825.05T	ERISYS LLC	98378248	SIGPRO	8	2024-01-26	2025-06-24	Y		$3,330
32224.02T	Moppie 31 LLC	98165120	RODTUX	8	2023-09-05	2025-05-20	Y		$4,530
33049.05	ONE CHOICE NUTRITION LLC	97678503	One Choice One Life ..	8	2023-09-13	2024-06-18	Y
13595.15T	Greatland Laser, LLC	97439068	rescue laser emergen..	8	2022-06-09	2023-05-02	Y
21887.21T	EZ Web Industries, Inc.	98858258	EZ TRUCK STORE	7	2024-11-18	2025-10-07	Y		$2,080
32224.03T	Moppie 31 LLC	98165158	Miscellaneous Design	7	2023-09-05	2025-05-20	Y		$4,530
28430.50T	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	98594826	THERAPEUTIC VISION, ..	7	2024-06-11	2025-04-29	Y		$3,910
28430.49T	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	98593436	THERAPEUTIC VISION, ..	7	2024-06-10	2025-04-15	Y		$3,410
32201.08T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	98027421	BRAIN SMACK	7	2023-06-05	2024-10-22	Y		$2,680
22795.01T	Kuhns, Duane H.	98081880	AUTHENTIC AMISH	7	2023-07-12	2024-06-07	Y		$3,110
200718.00T	Texas Coble, Ltd.	98105178	Lake Creek Pet Lodge..	6	2023-08-28	2025-08-09	Y		$2,140
32201.09T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	98604120	JELL-EEZ	6	2024-06-17	2025-05-20	Y		$2,380
32201.10T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	98604132	JELL-EEZ	6	2024-06-17	2025-05-20	Y		$2,380
00340.00T		97028221		6	2023-03-29	2025-03-19	Y
32825.07T	ERISYS LLC	98378261	QUADVU	6	2024-01-26	2025-03-11	Y		$3,660
12708.05T	Power Box Inc.	97916601	Eco-Box and Design	6	2023-05-02	2024-12-02	Y
200618.00T	The Celebrated Woman LLC	97692180	THE CELEBRATED WOMAN..	6	2022-12-19	2024-10-01	Y		$315
32993.04	Vaghi, Nino	88523469	PARK-N-RAIL	6	2023-01-03	2024-06-07	Y		$630
13595.16T	Greatland Laser, LLC	97271719	GREATLAND LASER	6	2022-12-08	2024-06-07	Y
33049.07T	ONE CHOICE NUTRITION LLC	98006931	One Choice One Life	6	2023-05-22	2024-06-07	Y
33048.01	Adhesif, LLC	88725941	ONE LINER	6	2022-12-02	2024-06-07	Y		$1,960
32201.21T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	99247515	MEGA MARSH MALLOW	5	2025-10-29	2025-12-30	Y
200340.00T	Zenobia International Invest..	97028221	KOOL CAP MAN	5	2023-03-30	2025-07-11	Y		$1,960
32201.12T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	98604146	SMACKeez and design	5	2024-06-17	2025-04-29	Y		$3,630
32201.14T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	98604156	eez and design	5	2024-06-17	2025-03-18	Y		$2,160
00400.00T		97212557		5	2023-08-18	2025-03-13	Y
19163.03T	MowCow Services, Inc.	97579216	Growcow	5	2023-06-21	2024-06-07	Y		$1,030
29920.15T	Hershey’s Metal Meister, LLC	97769609	Variobend U S A and ..	5	2023-01-26	2024-02-20	Y		$630
20888.03T	CORPORATE RENTALS, LLC	97287632	CR CORPORATE FURNITU..	5	2022-12-12	2023-10-16	Y
33048.00	Adhesif, LLC	88725938		5	2022-12-02	2023-08-15	Y		$630
32825.00	ERISYS LLC	87082316		4	2023-01-12	2026-01-24	Y
200911.06T	BHC Management, LLC	99034640	B H CELLULAR MEDICIN..	4	2025-07-09	2025-10-20	Y	4	$2,500
7781.09	Predator Racing Inc.	86437094	POUNCER	4	2024-06-10	2025-10-03	Y
32825.09T	ERISYS LLC	98966666	HyperVaul	4	2025-01-15	2025-09-22	Y		$2,280
32662.00	Active8Social, LLC	86260943		4	2022-02-15	2025-07-24	Y		$2,700
32201.11T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	98604138	SMACKeez	4	2024-06-17	2025-04-29	Y		$3,030
10788.05	Heartland Catfish Company, I..	88309842	HEARTLAND CATFISH an..	4	2024-06-07	2025-04-17	Y		$3,300
6217.49	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	88205155	COUPLE WITH PIZZA De..	4	2024-06-07	2025-04-16	Y		$2,270
32818.00	Capital Second Investments, ..	87062905		4	2024-06-12	2025-04-03	Y		$2,270
32201.13T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	98604150	eez	4	2024-06-17	2025-03-18	Y		$2,160
28430.51T	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	98595246	MFRM	4	2024-06-11	2025-03-10	Y		$2,580
00718.00T		98105178		4	2023-07-27	2025-02-20	Y
200400.00T	Reel, Daniel	97212557	SKORPION	4	2023-03-13	2024-09-09	Y		$2,025
00809.00T		98305568		4	2023-12-08	2024-08-14	Y
31929.01T	Flores, Vicky I.	97216426	CHORIZO SAN LUIS	4	2023-04-19	2024-07-01	Y		$1,680
33048.02T	Adhesif, LLC	98021247	ONE LINER	4	2023-05-31	2024-06-11	Y
32201.06T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	98009282	ANTORCHAS	4	2023-05-23	2024-06-04	Y		$630
32835.04T		97713165		4	2022-12-12	2024-01-23	Y
32999.16	Law Office of Bart S. Fisher	88369139	R 3A RPSCQC and Desi..	3	2025-05-12	2025-11-04	Y		$1,275
6217.50	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	88205019		3	2024-07-16	2025-10-30	Y
200911.05T	BHC Management, LLC	99034636	bhc MANAGEMENT and d..	3	2025-08-20	2025-10-21	Y	3	$2,500
32999.15	Law Office of Bart S. Fisher	88369134	R 3A RPSCQC	3	2025-05-12	2025-10-03	Y		$2,550
32380.22	Superior Products Internatio..	88174665	SPI COATINGS	3	2024-06-18	2025-08-04	Y		$3,900
32646.01	Schaich Bricken, Stephanie	86511315	PROTECTION PILLOW an..	3	2023-01-06	2025-07-26	Y
32646.06	Julia and Josephine, LLC	87687797	chakrashirt and desi..	3	2024-06-12	2025-05-13	Y
32980.01	Briscoe, James Dana	87759964	STALL RESCUE TOOL	3	2024-06-12	2025-05-05	Y
30449.02	National Association of Nutr..	88158043	BCHN	3	2024-12-03	2025-03-25	Y		$2,250
29682.03	Federal Hill Mortgage Compan..	87876035		Registrant: Federa..	3	2024-06-12	2025-03-24	Y
1389.01	Faswell Corporation	88135635	FASWELL and design	3	2024-05-21	2024-12-02	Y		$2,234
33049.02	Group SVM Inc.	86162962	CSARITE	3	2020-10-07	2024-10-06	Y
00711.01T		98209006		3	2023-10-04	2024-08-27	Y
22307.00	NILS, INC.	76532270		3	2024-05-13	2024-08-01	Y		$2,450
0525.32		74338700		3	2024-05-08	2024-08-01	Y
2414.69	Birch Horton Bittner and Che..	76456867	THE OTHER CAPE	3	2024-04-29	2024-07-26	Y		$2,450
22795.00	Kuhns, Duane H.	76517402		3	2024-04-02	2024-07-02	Y		$2,080
31241.03	Enviro-Cycle, LLC		RE-CRETE	3	2022-12-12	2024-06-13	Y
32442.00	Konekte Manufacturas S.A. de..			3	2023-08-08	2024-06-12	Y		$2,450
32542.00	Adams, Amy	85892197		3	2024-02-23	2024-06-12	Y		$2,450
24159.03	Schaller Corporation		SHAPING YOUR VISION	3	2023-07-20	2024-06-12	Y		$3,100
32994.00	XYANDZ LLC		GROUNDED AERIAL	3	2023-11-10	2024-06-12	Y		$1,795
12616.03	Galavis Hernandez, Ricardo		INSTANT INSTANT GLUE..	3	2023-03-23	2024-06-10	Y
20888.00	CORPORATE RENTALS, LLC			3	2023-08-22	2024-06-10	Y		$2,450
19197.01	Mac Rak, Inc.		MAC RAK	3	2023-03-27	2024-06-10	Y
29943.06	Davey (Valencia), Michelle		COOL DOWN ZONE	3	2023-01-19	2024-06-10	Y
21887.09	Ms. Carita Safetruck, Inc.			3	2023-03-22	2024-06-07	Y
11939.02	McCoy, LaTina D.		MOTHERS NURSER NURSI..	3	2023-10-18	2024-06-07	Y		$2,270
31964.03	Isaac Heating & Air Conditio..		WHEN YOU NEED US, WE..	3	2023-04-25	2024-06-07	Y
32712.01	Earthwalk Communications, In..		EARTHWALK	3	2023-03-29	2024-06-07	Y
2743.01		78798341		2	2024-06-13	2026-01-30	Y
32720.21	Kassel, Robert	88949422	Healthysole + and de..	2	2024-06-07	2026-01-05	Y
32520.05	Estetique Inc. USA	86939134	DERMAMAX	2	2024-06-10	2025-11-01	Y
15985.04	Alaska Game Bags, Inc.	88822732	ALASKA GAME BAGS	2	2024-06-07	2025-10-06	Y
32833.03	Alhuraibi, Shayma S J M	88698961	Keys 2 Architecture ..	2	2024-06-07	2025-09-15	Y
33051.00		88622953		2	2024-06-07	2025-06-23	Y
200713.01T	ScansX for Experimental Rese..	98677594	SCANSX and design	2	2025-02-17	2025-06-11	Y		$1,150
6217.31	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	74503222	SUGO design	2	2025-01-03	2025-06-11	Y		$2,450
6217.28	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	73502100	NICOLA PIZZA design	2	2025-01-03	2025-06-11	Y		$2,450
6217.38	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	76619762	NICOLA PIZZA design	2	2025-01-03	2025-06-11	Y		$2,450
32999.12	3-A Sanitary Standards Inc.	74627816	3 A and Design	2	2024-06-07	2025-05-28	Y
32752.02	FRS GmbH & Co. KG	86959530	FAST RELIABLE SEAWAY..	2	2025-01-08	2025-05-20	Y		$1,870
16725.03	James Hurysz and Helena Zink..	88445697	DATA QUALITY	2	2024-06-07	2025-04-28	Y
33003.00	Styles Fitness and Wellness,..	87859312	STYLES STUDIOS FITNE..	2	2024-06-07	2025-04-07	Y
21887.17	Ms. Carita, Inc.	88593878	Ms. CARITA INCORPORA..	2	2024-06-07	2025-04-07	Y
32996.01	Discover Science 4 Kids, LLC	87850041	MISS SCIENCE BECAUSE..	2	2024-11-04	2025-03-06	Y		$2,250
33040.00		88497267		2	2024-06-07	2025-02-18	Y
33045.00		88365821		2	2024-06-07	2024-12-31	Y
32999.01	3-A Sanitary Standards Inc.	87766580	3A	2	2024-07-31	2024-12-30	Y		$2,250
32380.19	Superior Products Internatio..	87473243	SPI and Design	2	2024-07-29	2024-12-28	Y		$2,250
32461.08	Eagle East Enterprises, LLC	88412144	HEMPSURE+	2	2024-06-07	2024-12-17	Y
6421.05	Masjid Muhammad, Inc.	86508228	MASJID MUHAMMAD THE ..	2	2024-06-12	2024-11-24	Y
2414.68	Birch Horton Bittner and Che..	76455162	KLC	2	2024-08-22	2024-11-22	Y		$2,450
28639.01	Barnes, Mark	86000716	MARCSTAR	2	2024-08-09	2024-11-07	Y
32471.01	Well Marriage Center, LLC	88360646	WELL MARRIAGE CENTER	2	2024-06-07	2024-10-15	Y
32825.01	ERISYS LLC	87619074	SPECTRUMVU	2	2024-04-03	2024-10-07	Y		$2,250
00711.00T		98209137		2	2023-10-04	2024-08-27	Y
00711.02T		98209014		2	2023-10-04	2024-08-27	Y
28708.03	Walter Francis dba Small Ele..	88290772		2	2024-06-07	2024-08-27	Y
15085.28	Becker, Theodore J.	86293882	ANALYZING THE EFFECT..	2	2024-06-04	2024-08-19	Y		$3,700
00809.01T		98463443		2	2024-03-22	2024-07-31	Y
2414.67	Birch Horton Bittner and Che..	76456837	KODIAK LAUNCH COMPLE..	2	2024-04-29	2024-07-23	Y		$2,450
15985.03	Rinio, Earl			2	2022-12-16	2024-06-10	Y
18805.01	Papelino, Jeannine		INTRE X DESIGN and D..	2	2023-02-25	2024-06-10	Y
4508.02	Anthony Welded Products, Inc..		ANTHONY and Design	2	2022-08-04	2024-06-10	Y
31320.03	Escalera, Inc.		COPYCADDY	2	2023-04-17	2024-06-10	Y
32825.04T	ERISYS LLC	97713165	LiveVu	2	2022-12-16	2024-06-10	Y		$1,300
28783.02	Heath, Michael A.	88817649	WHP GLOBAL CITIES an..	2	2020-09-25	2024-06-07	Y
19240.08	Schweer, James	90245024	Germafobies	2	2020-10-09	2024-06-07	Y
20365.03	Sea Lark Enterprises, Inc.		SOAP LIFT	2	2023-11-17	2024-06-07	Y
33081.00		90552095		2	2021-10-27	2024-06-07	Y
32269.11T	Outdoor Supply, Inc.	97055429	HARDCORE	2	2022-07-27	2024-06-07	Y
32214.03T	September 11th National Memo..	97070190	911 NATIONAL MEMORIA..	2	2023-01-03	2024-06-07	Y
00534.01T		97474121		2	2023-07-07	2024-06-07	Y
00618.00T		97692180		2	2024-05-28	2024-06-07	Y
32201.02	4 Aces Import, Inc.		Dulces Rey and Desig..	2	2023-03-07	2024-06-07	Y
12616.20	Galavis Hernandez, Ricardo			2	2023-12-01	2024-04-11	Y		$2,850
6217.15	Nicola Pizza, Inc.		NIC SPIN OLI and des..	2	2023-10-04	2024-03-13	Y		$2,450
12616.36	Servicios Corporativos de Ad..		Miscellaneous Design	2	2023-09-22	2024-03-07	Y		$2,450
6217.30	Nicola Pizza, Inc.			2	2023-09-13	2024-03-02	Y		$2,450
22586.00	Isaac Heating & Air Conditio..			2	2023-09-11	2024-03-01	Y		$2,450
12616.10	Servicios Corporativos de Ad..			2	2023-08-28	2024-02-21	Y		$2,470
12616.08	Servicios Corporativos de Ad..		ONE DROP IS ENOUGH	2	2023-08-25	2024-02-21	Y		$2,470
7781.06	Predator Racing Inc.		PROWLER	2	2023-07-17	2024-01-13	Y		$4,570
6217.46	Nicola Pizza, Inc.		NIC-O-BOLI	2	2023-07-17	2024-01-11	Y		$2,250
32449.01	Spotcity Cupcakes, LLC		SPOTCITY CUPCAKES, L..	2	2023-07-07	2024-01-04	Y
6217.14	Nicola Pizza, Inc.		Nicola’s Pasta Pail ..	2	2023-06-02	2023-11-29	Y
32752.00	FRS GmbH & Co. KG			2	2023-06-27	2023-10-30	Y
12616.02	Galavis Hernandez, Ricardo		INSTANT INSTANT GLUE..	2	2023-03-23	2023-09-27	Y
21887.10	EZ Web Industries, Inc.			2	2023-03-22	2023-09-23	Y
32752.03	FRS GmbH & Co. KG		FAST RELIABLE SEAWAY..	2	2023-04-07	2023-09-05	Y
29943.05	Davey (Valencia), Michelle		CUSTOMATIC DESIGNS	2	2023-01-19	2023-08-07	Y
21887.08	Ms. Carita, Inc.		MS. CARITA INCORPORA..	2	2023-01-27	2023-07-25	Y
32520.04	Estetique Inc. USA		ESTETIQUE	2	2022-12-14	2023-07-09	Y
3754.02	Superior Products Internatio..		SUPER THERM	2	2022-11-17	2023-06-14	Y
2414.79	Alaska SeaLife Center		ALASKA SEALIFE CENTE..	2	2022-12-01	2023-06-07	Y
33083.01	Fantasy Commodities, Inc.	90286872	F FANTASY COMMODITIE..	2	2021-12-13	2023-03-13	Y
33083.00	Fantasy Commodities, Inc.	90286858		2	2021-12-13	2023-03-13	Y
32712.03T	Earthwalk Communications, In..	97219208	SOLARWALK	2	2022-11-29	2023-02-14	Y
20365.15	Sea Lark Enterprises, Inc.	90482719	BEES SEES	2	2022-12-29	2023-01-31	Y
18654.01	Whiting, Vicki	90011056	KID SCOOP (Classes 9..	1	2026-01-26	2026-01-26	Y
32720.20	Healthy Sole, LLC	88949417		1	2026-01-12	2026-01-12	Y
11939.06	Baby 7 LLC	88933561	MOTHERS NURSER	1	2025-12-22	2025-12-22	Y
33052.00	The First Baptist Church of ..	88681904	FIRSTBIBLE	1	2025-12-15	2025-12-15	Y
25713.05	William Harmeyer & Associate..	76629333		1	2025-11-21	2025-11-21	Y
32201.20T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	99247507	TWISTEEZ MARSHMALLO..	1	2025-11-17	2025-11-17	Y
32201.19T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	99247500	TWISTEEZ MARSHMALLOW..	1	2025-11-17	2025-11-17	Y
32201.18T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	99247493	BRAIN STRIPS	1	2025-11-17	2025-11-17	Y
32201.17T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	99247490	BRAIN STRIPS	1	2025-11-17	2025-11-17	Y
33003.01	Styles Fitness and Wellness,..	88850407	HUSTLE @ HOME	1	2025-10-13	2025-10-13	Y
32471.02	Well Marriage Center, LLC	88605906	WELLMARRIAGE	1	2025-06-23	2025-06-23	Y
31964.06	Isaac Heating & Air Conditio..	88599483	ISAAC HEATING & AIR ..	1	2025-03-31	2025-03-31	Y
31964.05	Isaac Heating & Air Conditio..	88599475		1	2025-03-31	2025-03-31	Y
21887.14	Ms. Carita Safetruck, Inc.	88593859	BIGGER. STRONGER. SA..	1	2025-03-24	2025-03-24	Y
21887.15	Ms. Carita Safetruck, Inc.	88593864	SAFETRUCK	1	2025-03-24	2025-03-24	Y
21887.16	Ms. Carita Safetruck, Inc.	88593873	MS. CARITA	1	2025-03-24	2025-03-24	Y
21887.18	Ms. Carita, Inc.	88593880	RIGHT PEOPLE, RIGHT ..	1	2025-03-24	2025-03-24	Y
33039.00	Drishti Beats, LLC	88505211		1	2025-03-10	2025-03-10	Y
15085.29	Becker, Theodore J.	88452765	FRAUD FIND IT SOLVE ..	1	2024-12-24	2024-12-24	Y
200711.00T	SOURCE OF LIFE LIMITED	98209137	FIBERMATRIX	1	2024-12-10	2024-12-10	Y		$1,465
200711.02T	SOURCE OF LIFE LIMITED	98209014	VeCo Glow	1	2024-12-10	2024-12-10	Y		$1,465
200711.01T	SOURCE OF LIFE LIMITED	98209006	BIOABSORMIN	1	2024-12-10	2024-12-10	Y		$1,465
200809.01T	Natural Scientific Labs LLC	98463443	PREBIOFIBER	1	2024-12-10	2024-12-10	Y		$2,175
29943.10	Davey (Valencia), Michelle	88046581		1	2024-11-05	2024-11-05	Y
200809.00T	Natural Scientific Labs LLC	98305568	NATURAL SCIENTIFIC	1	2024-09-17	2024-09-17	Y		$2,540
32380.23	Superior Products Internatio..	88303566	SPI COATINGS PROVEN ..	1	2024-08-20	2024-08-20	Y
00713.01T		98677594		1	2024-08-01	2024-08-01	Y
14712.00				1	2024-06-14	2024-06-14	Y
12018.02	Savicki, Stanley D.		SIMPLE CHOICES FOR T..	1	2024-06-14	2024-06-14	Y
12018.01	Savicki, Stanley D.		CREMATION CARE CENTE..	1	2024-06-14	2024-06-14	Y
18708.00				1	2024-06-14	2024-06-14	Y
7429.00				1	2024-06-14	2024-06-14	Y
17821.00				1	2024-06-14	2024-06-14	Y
30224.00				1	2024-06-14	2024-06-14	Y
13437.03	Wilson, Keith W.		ARCHERY WORLD	1	2024-06-14	2024-06-14	Y
15991.03	Soul Purpose Productions, LL..		KARMAFEST	1	2024-06-14	2024-06-14	Y
30203.00				1	2024-06-14	2024-06-14	Y
30535.00	Three Rivers Bank of Montana		MISC. DESIGN	1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
22548.04	BESTechnologies, Inc.		OVAL-SHAPED “e” Desi..	1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
30854.00	The Maple Press Company		THINKTECH	1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
30850.00				1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
29777.01	SecureOne Benefit Administra..		PREFERRED UNITED PLA..	1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
5134.00				1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
3366.00				1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
2131.01	Westlake Hardware Inc.		WESTLAKE	1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
30978.03	Dotson, Kristy		TYMPLATES	1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
31693.00				1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
31627.00				1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
31929.00	Flores, Vicky I.			1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
31878.00	IDEXCEL, INC.			1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
29739.00	Herndon Brother's Inc.			1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
25407.01	Moritz, Joel M.		3RD HAND DISPENSER	1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
27181.03	The Trustees of the Ray & Pe..		TRUSSMATE	1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
33010.00				1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
29704.00				1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
28798.01	Data Distributing LLC		DISCO	1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
32539.00				1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
4851.16	USA United Suppliers of Amer..		ENVIRONMENTAL WATCHD..	1	2024-06-13	2024-06-13	Y
22617.00				1	2024-06-12	2024-06-12	Y
24295.05	Wilkinson, Lisa Diane Crisli..		DIAPER DESIGN	1	2024-06-12	2024-06-12	Y
32794.00	Haar, Christian			1	2024-06-12	2024-06-12	Y
28430.01	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.		KINOSTAT	1	2024-06-11	2024-06-11	Y
14905.07	International Management Con..		IMCI TECHNOLOGIES	1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
30532.01	Alliance of Hazardous Materi..		ALLIANCE OF HAZARDOU..	1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
15985.02	Alaska Game Bags, Inc.		Alaska Gamebags, Inc..	1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
6254.09	Lefty's Barbecue Unlimited, ..		Design - Portrait of..	1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
6254.05	Lefty's Spices, LLC		LEFTY’S	1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
31395.00	Stewart, Linda E.		NANNY'S	1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
32752.04T	FRS GmbH & Co. KG		FRS and Design	1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
32752.01	FRS GmbH & Co. KG		Misc. Design	1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
32999.04	Give Life Foundation, Inc.		GIVE LIFE FOUNDATION	1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
32996.00	Discover Science 4 Kids, LLC			1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
29920.08	Hershey’s Metal Meister, LLC		VARIOBEND USA and de..	1	2024-06-10	2024-06-10	Y
15085.23	Becker, Theodore J.		BEC BIOMECHANICAL	1	2024-06-07	2024-06-07	Y
3754.72	Superior Products Internatio..		HPC	1	2024-06-07	2024-06-07	Y
33050.00				1	2024-06-07	2024-06-07	Y
27375.00	Clear Sky Holdings, LLC			1	2024-06-07	2024-06-07	Y
27375.04	Clear Sky Holdings, LLC		SURVIVING TO THRIVIN..	1	2024-06-07	2024-06-07	Y
18654.00	Whiting, Vicki			1	2024-06-07	2024-06-07	Y
33078.00	ISAAC TEC LLC			1	2024-06-07	2024-06-07	Y
33052.01	The First Baptist Church of ..		FIRSTBIBLE SCHOOL OF..	1	2024-06-07	2024-06-07	Y
33039.02	Drishti Beats, LLC		DRISHTI BEATS	1	2024-06-07	2024-06-07	Y
29920.09	Hershey’s Metal Meister, LLC		VARIOBEND USA	1	2024-06-07	2024-06-07	Y
32380.16	Superior Products Internatio..	85932849	SPI COATINGS PROVEN ..	1	2024-05-19	2024-05-19	Y
200534.01T	Qasem, Sadeq	97474121	Dukhoon and design	1	2024-01-30	2024-01-30	Y		$1,715
32520.03	Estetique Inc. USA		REJUVEMAX	1	2023-07-07	2023-07-07	Y
18805.00	Papelino, Jeannine			1	2023-02-25	2023-02-25	Y
32201.03	Rupani, Arman		4A 4 ACES IMPORT and..	1	2023-02-09	2023-02-09	Y
32999.11	3-A Sanitary Standards Inc.		3 A and Design	1	2023-01-21	2023-01-21	Y
32214.02	September 11th National Memo..	90533930	SEPTEMBER 11TH NATIO..	1	2022-07-26	2022-07-26	Y

8. Statute of Limitations Period Analysis

Every email is categorized by its date relative to the key SOL cutoff dates:

Period	Date Range	Email Count	Percentage	Significance
Pre-SOL	Before 6/15/2020	0	0.0%	Outside statute of limitations
Post-SOL	6/15/2020 - 7/20/2024	491	65.6%	Within SOL; actionable uses
Post-SOL-Safe	7/21/2024 onward	257	34.4%	Strongest evidence -- most recent, undeniable
TOTAL		748	100%

All 748 emails fall within the actionable period (after 6/15/2020). There are zero pre-SOL emails in this dataset, meaning every single USPTO trademark email to Litman's address is an actionable use of his name.

By Docket (classified by most recent email):

Post-SOL dockets (last email before 7/21/2024): 130
Post-SOL-Safe dockets (last email on/after 7/21/2024): 115
Total active dockets: 245

Monthly Email Volume (2024-2026)

Month	Emails
2024-01	21
2024-02	15
2024-03	21
2024-04	19
2024-05	15
2024-06	156
2024-07	17
2024-08	21
2024-09	11
2024-10	10
2024-11	12
2024-12	23
2025-01	29
2025-02	19
2025-03	24
2025-04	20
2025-05	14
2025-06	17
2025-07	11
2025-08	9
2025-09	2
2025-10	11
2025-11	9
2025-12	4
2026-01	5

9. Co-Recipient Analysis

NGM Staff Recipients

Recipient	Email Count	Percentage	Role
docketing@nathlaw.com	739	98.8%	NGM Docketing Department
hkline@nathlaw.com	702	93.9%	Howard Kline -- Trademark attorney handling these matters
docketingnva@nathlaw.com	146	19.5%	NGM Northern Virginia docketing
tm@nathlaw.com	20	2.7%	NGM Trademark mailbox
jgoldberg@nathlaw.com	18	2.4%	Joshua B. Goldberg -- Defendant

Goldberg's Direct Involvement

Joshua B. Goldberg (jgoldberg@nathlaw.com) appears as a co-recipient on the following 18 emails, proving his direct awareness that Litman's name was being used on these matters:

Date	Docket	Subject	Serial No.
2025-10-21	200911.05T	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 99034636 -- Docket/Re..	99034636
2025-10-20	200911.06T	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 99034640 -- Docket/Re..	99034640
2025-08-26	200911.06T	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 99034640 -- Docket/Re..	99034640
2025-08-26	200911.05T	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 99034636 -- Docket/Re..	99034636
2025-08-20	200911.06T	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 99034640 -- Docket/Re..	99034640
2025-08-20	200911.05T	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 99034636 -- Docket/Re..	99034636
2025-07-21	N/A	U.S. Trademark Application Serial No. 99034640 - B H CELLULAR MEDICINE - 200911..	99034640
2025-07-21	N/A	U.S. Trademark Application Serial No. 99034644 - IMPS - 200911.04T	99034644
2025-07-09	200911.06T	Official USPTO Notification: U.S. Trademark Application SN 99034640 -- Docket/Re..	99034640
2025-02-10	N/A	The USPTO has received your trademark application (serial number 99034644)	99034644
2025-02-10	N/A	The USPTO has received your trademark application (serial number 99034640)	99034640
2025-02-10	N/A	The USPTO has received your trademark application (serial number 99034636)	99034636
2023-05-10	N/A	TTAB Order - Do Not Reply By E-mail. Mail Box Not Monitored - proceeding 9208130..	N/A
2023-03-28	N/A	TTAB Order - Do Not Reply By E-mail. Mail Box Not Monitored - proceeding 9208130..	N/A
2023-02-03	N/A	Motion to extend time to answer granted - proceeding no. 92081302	N/A
2023-02-03	N/A	ESTTA Filing Receipt: Proceeding or Serial or Registration No. 92081302 Stipulat..	N/A
2023-01-30	N/A	ESTTA Filing Receipt: Proceeding or Serial or Registration No. 92081302 Change o..	N/A
2022-03-07	N/A	Motion to suspend granted - proceeding no. 92078220	N/A

Third-Party (Client) Co-Recipients

The following non-NGM email addresses appeared as co-recipients on USPTO emails alongside rlitman@nathlaw.com. These are clients who received official government correspondence listing Litman as the attorney of record:

Client Email	Email Count	Associated Docket(s)
arman@4acesdallas.com	10	32201.06T, 32201.07T, 32201.08T
dave.erisman@erisys.com	5	32825.00, 32825.05T, 32825.06T
jamesdbriscoe@gmail.com	4	32980.01
ssbricken@gmail.com	3	32646.01
pkassel@healthysole.com	2	32720.20, 32720.21
office@1choicenutrition.com	2	33049.05, 33049.07T
patriciaaboye@gmail.com	2	33048.00, 33048.01
kim.erickson@greatlandlaser.com	2	13595.15T, 13595.16T
bart_fisher2002@yahoo.com	2	33083.00, 33083.01
JGoldberg@Nathlaw.com	2
tbaxter@911trail.org	2	32214.02, 32214.03T
vicki@kidscoop.com	1	18654.01
baby7@comcast.net	1	11939.06
tsegebre@estetique.com	1	32520.05
rinioew@frontiernet.net	1	15985.04
bo@jbrex.com	1	12708.06T
brad@hersheysmm.com	1	29920.17T
patsyedwards1@verizon.net	1	200618.00T
anthony@hashtagsports.com	1
info@sadeq.me	1	200534.01T
tjbecker210@gmail.com	1
richard@mowcow.com	1	19163.03T
jsenker@corporaterentals.com	1	20888.03T
sofiyac@earthwalk.com	1	32712.03T
bill@soaplift.com	1	20365.15

Total unique client email addresses appearing as co-recipients: 25

10. Financial Cross-Reference

Of the 245 trademark dockets that generated USPTO emails to Litman, 83 dockets have documented payment data in NGM's financial records.

Total documented payments across these dockets: $203,200.68

This figure represents the commercial value extracted by NGM from matters where Litman's name remained as attorney of record. The actual revenue is likely substantially higher, as:

Payment data covers only July 2023 through May 2025
Many dockets with USPTO emails have no matching payment records in the available data
Attorney fees, filing fees, and soft costs are all included

Top Revenue-Generating Dockets

Docket	Client	Total Paid	Emails	Date Range
32825.06T	ERISYS LLC	$6,610.00	10	2024-01-26 to 2025-08-26
7781.06	Predator Racing Inc.	$4,570.00	2	2023-07-17 to 2024-01-13
32224.02T	Moppie 31 LLC	$4,530.00	8	2023-09-05 to 2025-05-20
32224.03T	Moppie 31 LLC	$4,530.00	7	2023-09-05 to 2025-05-20
26363.06T	Champion, Mark E.	$3,920.00	13	2023-02-08 to 2025-04-03
28430.50T	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	$3,910.00	7	2024-06-11 to 2025-04-29
32380.22	Superior Products Internationa..	$3,900.00	3	2024-06-18 to 2025-08-04
32201.07T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	$3,740.00	9	2023-06-05 to 2024-10-22
15085.28	Becker, Theodore J.	$3,700.00	2	2024-06-04 to 2024-08-19
32825.07T	ERISYS LLC	$3,660.00	6	2024-01-26 to 2025-03-11
32201.12T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	$3,630.00	5	2024-06-17 to 2025-04-29
28430.49T	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	$3,410.00	7	2024-06-10 to 2025-04-15
32825.05T	ERISYS LLC	$3,330.00	8	2024-01-26 to 2025-06-24
6217.51T	Nicola Pizza, Inc.	$3,300.00	9	2024-04-15 to 2025-07-30
10788.05	Heartland Catfish Company, Inc..	$3,300.00	4	2024-06-07 to 2025-04-17
22795.01T	Kuhns, Duane H.	$3,110.00	7	2023-07-12 to 2024-06-07
24159.03	Schaller Corporation	$3,100.00	3	2023-07-20 to 2024-06-12
32201.11T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	$3,030.00	4	2024-06-17 to 2025-04-29
29920.17T	Hershey’s Metal Meister, LLC	$2,920.00	11	2023-01-25 to 2024-10-29
12616.20	Galavis Hernandez, Ricardo	$2,850.00	2	2023-12-01 to 2024-04-11
32662.00	Active8Social, LLC	$2,700.00	4	2022-02-15 to 2025-07-24
32201.08T	4 Aces Import, Inc.	$2,680.00	7	2023-06-05 to 2024-10-22
28430.51T	Therapeutic Vision, Inc.	$2,580.00	4	2024-06-11 to 2025-03-10
32999.15	Law Office of Bart S. Fisher	$2,550.00	3	2025-05-12 to 2025-10-03
200809.00T	Natural Scientific Labs LLC	$2,540.00	1	2024-09-17 to 2024-09-17
200911.06T	BHC Management, LLC	$2,500.00	4	2025-07-09 to 2025-10-20
200911.05T	BHC Management, LLC	$2,500.00	3	2025-08-20 to 2025-10-21
12616.10	Servicios Corporativos de Admi..	$2,470.00	2	2023-08-28 to 2024-02-21
12616.08	Servicios Corporativos de Admi..	$2,470.00	2	2023-08-25 to 2024-02-21
22307.00	NILS, INC.	$2,450.00	3	2024-05-13 to 2024-08-01

11. The "Deck of Cards" Count -- Separate Section 51 Publications

Under the legal theory that each use of Litman's name constitutes a separate actionable publication under NY Civil Rights Law Section 51, the following counts apply to USPTO trademark emails alone:

Category	Count
Total USPTO trademark emails to rlitman@nathlaw.com	748
Emails where Litman was in the TO field	530
Emails where Litman was in the CC field	218
Unique trademark dockets using Litman's name	245
Unique clients affected	115
Emails with third-party (client) co-recipients	48
Post-SOL-Safe emails (7/21/2024+)	257

Each of these 748 emails is a separate, documentable instance of Litman's name being used in connection with commercial trademark work. Combined with the 905 patent front pages (each a separate use), the 206 outgoing USPTO patent documents, and the website publications, the total number of Section 51 violations reaches into the thousands.

These are not theoretical or inferred uses. Each email exists as a digital record with a timestamp, sender (the United States Patent and Trademark Office), and recipients -- including Litman's name and professional email address. The USPTO would not have sent these emails unless Litman's credentials remained on file as the attorney of record.

Cumulative Section 51 Publication Count

Source	Count
Patent front pages (Line 74)	905
Outgoing USPTO patent documents (IFW)	206
USPTO trademark emails (this exhibit)	748
Website appearances (nathlaw.com)	7+
TOTAL DOCUMENTED SECTION 51 PUBLICATIONS	1866+

12. Source Files

File	Description
`USPTO_EMAILS_TO_LITMAN.csv`	Primary dataset: 748 USPTO emails with date, sender, recipients, subject, and Litman position
`KLINE_DOCKET_FINANCIAL_CROSSREF.csv`	Howard Kline trademark docket cross-reference with client names and financial data (309 dockets)
`20250616_All_7digit_Matters.csv`	NGM complete matters database with client contact information (6,643 matters)
`20250616_Payments_0723-0525_bydate.csv`	NGM payment records July 2023 through May 2025 (2,973 entries)
`USPTO_TRADEMARK_DOCKET_MAP.csv`	Summary docket map generated from this analysis (245 dockets)

This exhibit was compiled from email records and NGM financial data. All dates, docket numbers, and serial numbers are taken directly from USPTO correspondence. Client identifications are cross-referenced against NGM's own internal matter management records.

Uspto Trademark Name Use Exhibit