Qatar Foundation (QF) Exhibit Candidate Inventory
Window: 6/14/2023 (arbitration award) → 7/18/2025 (termination)
Theory: NY Civil Rights Law § 51 — Martha/NGM → QF emails with USPTO attachments are dated commercial uses of Richard Litman's name.
Source: output/qf_email_docket_detail.csv (56 in-window NGM→QF emails) enriched with attachment metadata from discovery_production/DATA/LITMAN_EMAIL_PRODUCTION.dat.
Recipient domains matched: @qf\.org\.qa|qf@4patent\.com
Headline numbers
- 56 NGM→QF emails in the post-arbitration window.
- 55 pass the baseline candidate filter (from NGM, to QF, has attachment).
- 42 are USPTO-document-like candidates.
- 54.8% have a subject-line attachment descriptor.
- 16 distinct dockets represented.
Top 20 dockets by email volume
| Rank |
Docket |
# Emails |
First |
Last |
Top attachment types |
| 1 |
33005.72 |
5 |
2024-06-27 |
2024-09-19 |
Office Action (3), Application/Spec (2) |
| 2 |
33005.76 |
5 |
2023-07-31 |
2023-11-13 |
Application/Spec (3), Other/Unclassified (2) |
| 3 |
33046.02 |
4 |
2024-05-07 |
2024-08-26 |
Other/Unclassified (4) |
| 4 |
33005.83 |
3 |
2023-10-17 |
2023-11-13 |
Application/Spec (3) |
| 5 |
32605.29 |
2 |
2024-02-29 |
2024-04-18 |
Other/Unclassified (2) |
| 6 |
32705.38 |
2 |
2024-11-26 |
2024-11-26 |
Other/Unclassified (2) |
| 7 |
33005.05 |
2 |
2023-06-26 |
2023-07-05 |
Other/Unclassified (2) |
| 8 |
33005.77 |
2 |
2023-07-06 |
2024-06-05 |
Office Action (1), Other/Unclassified (1) |
| 9 |
33005.78 |
2 |
2023-12-12 |
2023-12-12 |
Application/Spec (2) |
| 10 |
33046.14 |
2 |
2024-02-29 |
2024-03-26 |
Other/Unclassified (2) |
| 11 |
32905.14 |
1 |
2023-09-18 |
2023-09-18 |
Other/Unclassified (1) |
| 12 |
33005.38 |
1 |
2023-08-01 |
2023-08-01 |
Other/Unclassified (1) |
| 13 |
33005.64 |
1 |
2023-07-02 |
2023-07-02 |
Other/Unclassified (1) |
| 14 |
33005.91 |
1 |
2023-07-18 |
2023-07-18 |
Other/Unclassified (1) |
| 15 |
33046.01 |
1 |
2023-12-12 |
2023-12-12 |
Office Action (1), Application/Spec (1) |
| 16 |
33046.04 |
1 |
2023-11-24 |
2023-11-24 |
Other/Unclassified (1) |
Top 20 inferred attachment types
| Rank |
Attachment type |
Count |
% of candidates |
| 1 |
Other/Unclassified |
25 |
59.5% |
| 2 |
Application/Spec |
12 |
28.6% |
| 3 |
Office Action |
6 |
14.3% |
Date distribution (by quarter)
| Quarter |
# candidates |
| 2023Q2 |
1 |
| 2023Q3 |
9 |
| 2023Q4 |
10 |
| 2024Q1 |
4 |
| 2024Q2 |
7 |
| 2024Q3 |
6 |
| 2024Q4 |
5 |
Files produced
output/QF_EXHIBIT_CANDIDATES_RANKED.csv — full ranked roster (42 rows).output/QF_EXHIBIT_CANDIDATES_BY_DOCKET.csv — per-docket roll-up (16 rows).output/QF_EXHIBIT_INVENTORY_MEMO.md — this memo.