Date compiled: 2026-04-10 Source: Richard Litman's phone (iCloud Photos / nathlawImages folder) Total photos reviewed: 176 Date range of evidence: June 7, 2020 through September 18, 2025 Date range of screenshots: July 8, 2025 through September 15, 2025 Batch files: 6 (IMG_0109-0447, IMG_0526-0604, IMG_0616-0749, IMG_1232-1466, IMG_1501-1635, IMG_1648-1724 + Screenshot 2025-09-09)
176 photos from Richard Litman's phone were reviewed across 6 batch files. The photos span evidence creation dates from June 2020 through September 2025, with screenshots captured by Litman between July 8 and September 15, 2025, as he systematically documented the misappropriation of his name and professional identity.
Categories breakdown:
| Category | Count |
|---|---|
| Wayback Machine nathlaw.com captures | ~35 |
| Google search results | ~25 |
| Trademark client correspondence/emails | ~15 |
| Email threads (CASE Act, KSU, KFU, etc.) | ~25 |
| Financial documents (invoices, wires, statements) | ~8 |
| USPTO trademark filings/notices | ~8 |
| Client goodwill emails | ~6 |
| Text message screenshots | ~2 |
| Website screenshots (litmanlaw.com, DDI, live nathlaw.com) | ~5 |
| LinkedIn messaging | ~1 |
| Martha Long daily work emails | ~12 |
| Heba Carter termination letter | ~2 |
| ChatGPT/Archive.today analysis | ~2 |
| Exhibit-prepared redacted/annotated versions | ~8 |
| Duplicates/alternate crops | ~22 |
Key finding categories established: - Website name-use from June 2020 through August 23, 2025 (Wayback) and possibly September 5, 2025 - Post-email-elimination (July 18, 2025) continued name use in client letters, trademark filings, and official USPTO correspondence - Six named goodwill clients documented - March 2021 email thread with explosive financial admissions from Goldberg and Meyer - Four deliberate patent abandonments in 18 days post-termination - Contemporaneous emotional distress evidence - Client renumbering scheme documented in Litman's own words
Source: IMG_0744, IMG_0747 Date: March 5-8, 2021 Goldberg writes: "the amounts we owe to you" and later quantifies it: "$41,493.71 due to you. For January and February, there is an additional $7,591.46 due to you, making the total at $49,085.17." This is a direct party admission of debt with a specific dollar amount. Goldberg also offers: "we can certainly set them aside in a trust account for you so you can see the money is there."
Source: IMG_0625, IMG_1653, IMG_1666, IMG_1677, IMG_1704, IMG_1724, Screenshot 2025-09-09 Significance: Wayback Machine capture from August 23, 2025 shows Litman's full individual bio page at nathlaw.com/richard-c-litman/ still active, titled "RICHARD C. LITMAN, PATENT ATTORNEY" (no "Retired"), with present-tense language ("is a Patent Attorney"). This is more than 2 months after his June 10, 2025 removal demand and more than 1 month after the July 18, 2025 email elimination. Extends previously documented Finding #6 by 2 full months.
Source: IMG_0749 (goodwill letter), IMG_0677/IMG_1684 (filing errors) Date: September 17-18, 2025 Dvorkin's full September 18 letter states: "I turned to your firm, Nath, Goldberg & Meyer, for the preparation and registration of my new patent solely for the reason that Mr. Richard Litman works with you." One day earlier (September 17), Dvorkin emailed Litman to report FOUR errors in his patent: wrong patent name, wrong application number, wrong inventor name ("Dr. Thamer" instead of Dvorkin), and wrong payment form. He paid $20,000. "What is happened in your company?" Proves both goodwill attraction AND actual client harm from post-Litman quality deterioration.
Source: IMG_0542, IMG_0543, IMG_0562, IMG_0627, IMG_1612, IMG_1629, IMG_1665, IMG_1674, IMG_1689, IMG_1711 Date: July 24, 2025 Client letter to Activ8Social/Hashtag Sports on NGM letterhead signed "Richard C. Litman / Howard W. Kline" -- SIX DAYS after the July 18 email elimination. The accompanying email (IMG_0543, IMG_1628) CC'd rlitman@nathlaw.com. Either the email was still active (contradicting the elimination claim) or Kline was CC'ing a dead address while using Litman's name on client letters.
Source: IMG_0741-0747 Date: March 5-9, 2021
From Goldberg: - "the amounts we owe to you" -- direct admission of debt - "$49,085.17" owed -- quantified - "the amounts owed you to start getting some of the back-logged KSU applications filed" -- using Litman's money for KSU filings - "thank you for offering to help, without a paycheck" -- Litman working without pay
From Jerry Meyer: - "5-year tail of the agreement" -- agreement still in force - "we are happy to put it aside in a trust account" -- trust account commitment - "multi-million dollar receivable" -- KSU scale acknowledged - Bank concerns about the KSU receivable
From Litman: - "Our deal was for NGM to buy my practice" -- practice sale characterization - "$25,000/month as a W-2 employee as an advance, trued up quarterly per contract" -- payment baseline - "the 80% due NGM" -- confirms 20% formula (Finding #66) - "money owed me --- interest free" -- offering NGM interest-free loan of his own unpaid earnings - Contract triggers: "death or disqualification to practice law" -- disability NOT a termination event - "what's due me for October, November, December, January and February as agreed for purchase of the practice"
Source: IMG_0545, IMG_0600, IMG_0601, IMG_0603, IMG_0604, IMG_0616, IMG_1501-1503, IMG_1670 Litman appeared on at least 5 separate nathlaw.com pages: 1. /professionals/ (main professionals page) 2. /richard-c-litman/ (individual bio page) 3. /professionals/electrical-mechanical-and-chemical-engineering-departments/ 4. /professionals/trademarks-and-copyrights-department/ -- Litman was the SOLE listing 5. /professionals/commercialization-and-licensing/
Each page is a separate "publication" under Section 51.
Source: IMG_1552 NGM contact form: "a customer of Richard Litman's from way back... I thought the world of Mr. Litman." Bennington explicitly identifies his prior relationship with Litman and apologizes for going elsewhere. Direct proof that Litman's name attracted clients to the firm.
Source: IMG_0736, IMG_0737 Date: June 7-8, 2020 (8 days before SOL cutoff) Goldberg writes: "my strong preference is that we keep this between you and I" regarding both Jerry Meyer's health issues and Litman's disability. "There is absolutely no need to give our clients any (unjustified) reason to worry about our performance or capabilities." This is the genesis of the name-use pattern -- the deliberate decision to keep Litman's name prominent while concealing his actual role. Re Middle East clients specifically: "we have not been saying anything, nor do I think we should."
Source: IMG_1329, IMG_1402 Formal letter from NGM's counsel: email access promised until "August 30, 2025 as a courtesy." But emails were actually eliminated on July 18 -- 43 days early. Proves acceleration/retaliation. Also confirms June 30, 2025 benefits cutoff (triggering COBRA damages of $2,867.11/month) and attempts res judicata argument on pre-arbitration claims.
Source: IMG_1440, IMG_1455 June 18, 2025: THREE abandonments (Dockets 33150.43U, 33110.48U, 33125.42A). July 2, 2025: ONE abandonment (Docket 33120.42A). Docket 33110.48U was a KFU case with $11,840 in paid-but-unallocated fees. Cases being abandoned after fees were collected.
Source: IMG_1414 Date: June 16, 2025 Litman's own email describes the diversion mechanism: "I've identified that several clients have been assigned multiple NGM client numbers, particularly those beginning with '1'. This creates a concerning scenario: if client deposits are processed through one client number (typically starting with '1') while my allocation calculations are based on payments associated with a different client number originally assigned by NGM, no allocation would be triggered for my allocation." Source for Finding #27.
Source: IMG_0447 LinkedIn DM from a prospective trademark client reaching out to Litman by name, seeking services and a quote. Litman refers her to Howard Kline at NGM. Joins Bennington, Albannai, Dvorkin, Dakota AG/Odland, and Dr. Al-Refaei.
Source: IMG_1565, IMG_1630 Date: October 8-9, 2024 Client writes: "Our experience with The Litman Law office was such that we are not interested in looking elsewhere as long as you are carrying on the same quality." Litman himself responds from rlitman@nathlaw.com -- proving active client engagement 4+ years post-"termination."
Source: IMG_1411 Date: June 19, 2025 Three specific KFU invoices (405540, 405629, 405664) totaling $35,120 were paid but allocation is missing. Litman documented this to accountant Deborah Schaefer four days after the SOL date. Also states "our firm successfully obtained 631 patents for King Faisal University in 2024, making them the leading university worldwide for US patents obtained that year."
Source: IMG_1417 Date: June 11, 2025 Goldberg writes: "For KFU, you should clearly receive your percentage of any non-USPTO fees we received. If that is not happening, I need to figure out why to make sure it does not continue, as well as to make up any payments that would have been missed." Also: "many of them are blank" (re trust ledgers). Source for Finding #53.
Source: IMG_0422 Date: July 14, 2025 www.litmanlaw.com "Arabic IP Practice" page still live, promoting the Gulf/Middle East client portfolio. A distinct website bearing Litman's name, connected to NGM operations. Active one month after the June 15, 2025 "especially problematic" cutoff.
Source: IMG_1429, IMG_1466 Independent third-party capture from Archive.today confirms Litman listed as "PATENT ATTORNEY" on nathlaw.com Commercialization & Licensing page through July 1, 2025 -- extending the evidence chain 10 days beyond the June 21 Wayback capture.
Source: IMG_1462 Direct browser screenshot of live nathlaw.com showing "Richard C. Litman, PATENT ATTORNEY" with photo. Title bar reference "01.23" suggests January 23, 2025 capture date. Not a Wayback capture -- actual live website.
Source: IMG_1447 Martha Long email: "Docket 32715.79X -- Signed power of attorney to be filed with assignment." A POA filing TEN DAYS after the Agreement terminated (June 15, 2025). May be the latest-dated POA filing documented.
Source: IMG_1297 MaryJane Harper set up Litman's Soluno login (rlitman@nathlaw.com, temp password Welcome1!) on October 28, 2024 -- contradicts any claim of firm separation.
Source: IMG_1408 Litman emails Goldberg and Meyer proposing CASE Act (copyright small-claims) practice for NGM. Active business development 9 months post-SOL cutoff -- rebutting "disability = death" defense.
Source: IMG_0393-0395 Section 8/9 combined declaration filed December 12, 2022, listing Richard C. Litman as current and proposed attorney with Goldberg, Meyer, Kline, and Harkins as additional appointed attorneys.
Source: IMG_1276 Text message from Litman same day as email elimination: "Same with NathLaw.com. This whole thing is really affecting me." The next day he sends KFU Trust Flow forensic analysis.
Source: IMG_0732 March 2023 email from Goldberg discussing a $1,437,568 KSU wire transfer plus $129,650 in expected but unreceived KSU payments from 2018 invoices still showing as open receivables.
Source: IMG_0109 April 2017 email confirms 2430 20th Street NW, Washington DC 20009 as Goldberg's home address, used for NGM corporate filings. Confirms NGM is a DC corporation.
| Date | Source | Page | Litman's Title | Capture Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ~Jan 23, 2025 | IMG_1462 | /professionals/ | PATENT ATTORNEY | Live browser |
| Jul 14, 2025 | IMG_0422 | www.litmanlaw.com (Arabic IP Practice) | N/A (entire site is "Litman Law") | Live browser |
| Date | Source | Page | Litman's Title |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feb 19, 2025 | IMG_0600 | /professionals/electrical-mechanical-and-chemical-engineering-departments/ | PATENT ATTORNEY |
| Feb 19, 2025 | IMG_0601 | /professionals/trademarks-and-copyrights-department/ | PATENT ATTORNEY (SOLE listing) |
| Apr 28, 2025 | IMG_0545, IMG_0558, IMG_0603 | /professionals/ and /commercialization-and-licensing/ | PATENT ATTORNEY |
| Jun 21, 2025 | IMG_0546-0551, IMG_0604, IMG_0616 | /richard-c-litman/ and department pages | PATENT ATTORNEY (no "Retired") |
| Aug 23, 2025 | IMG_0625, IMG_1653, IMG_1666, IMG_1677, IMG_1704 | /richard-c-litman/ and /professionals/ | PATENT ATTORNEY (no "Retired") |
| Date | Source | Page | Litman's Title |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2025 | IMG_1429, IMG_1466 | /commercialization-and-licensing/ | PATENT ATTORNEY |
| Date Indexed | Source | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Jun 14, 2024 | IMG_0397, IMG_0438, IMG_1635 | /commercialization-and-licensing/ -- "Richard C. Litman PATENT ATTORNEY" (no Retired) |
| Jan 17, 2022 | IMG_0396, IMG_1635 | /sitemap -- lists "RICHARD C. LITMAN" under Trademarks And Copyrights Department |
| Jun 25, 2025 | IMG_0386, IMG_0538, IMG_1568, IMG_1693, IMG_1635 | /richard-c-litman/ -- "RICHARD C. LITMAN, PATENT ATTORNEY, Retired" |
| Event | Date | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Litman demands removal from website | Jun 10, 2025 | Finding #33 |
| Last Wayback showing "PATENT ATTORNEY" (no Retired) | Jun 21, 2025 | IMG_0546 |
| Google indexes page with "Retired" added | ~Jun 25, 2025 | IMG_0538, IMG_1693 |
| Litigation trigger ("gets you into litigation") | Jun 26, 2025 | Finding #35 |
| Archive.today still shows "PATENT ATTORNEY" (no Retired) on dept page | Jul 1, 2025 | IMG_1429 |
| Bio page still on Wayback as "PATENT ATTORNEY" (no Retired) | Aug 23, 2025 | IMG_0625, IMG_1653 |
| Litman removed entirely from nathlaw.com | By Sep 5, 2025 | Finding #6 |
Key insight: NGM's response to Litman's June 10 removal demand was NOT to remove the page but to add "(Retired)" around June 25. The page, photo, and full biographical details REMAINED publicly accessible. The bio page on Wayback still showed "PATENT ATTORNEY" without "Retired" as late as August 23, suggesting the Wayback capture preserved the pre-modification state. By September 5, Litman was removed entirely.
| Site | Litman's Listed Title | Source |
|---|---|---|
| RocketReach | Senior Counsel | IMG_0424, IMG_0444 |
| Growjo | Senior Counsel | IMG_0444 |
| Datanyze | Senior Counsel | IMG_0444 |
| Success.ai | Senior Counsel | IMG_0423 |
| Experience.com | Intellectual Property Attorney | IMG_1635 |
| PatentBuddy | Patent Dept Attorney | IMG_0425 |
| ZoomInfo | Employee | IMG_0396 |
| Senior Counsel @ NGM, Brooklyn, NY | IMG_0436 | |
| Florida Bar | Eligible to practice, mail address NGM, email litman@4patent.com | IMG_0423, IMG_0424 |
| MapQuest | "Litman Law Ltd" at 112 S West St, Alexandria | IMG_0396 |
Everything below occurred AFTER Goldberg claims Litman's email accounts were eliminated on July 18, 2025.
| Date | Document | Litman's Role | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 24, 2025 | Hashtag Sports letter on NGM letterhead | Printed name "Richard C. Litman" in signature block | IMG_0542, IMG_1612, IMG_1665, IMG_1674 |
| Jul 24, 2025 | Hashtag Sports email (Kline to client) | CC: rlitman@nathlaw.com | IMG_0543, IMG_1628 |
| Jul 25, 2025 | QUICK BIB TM renewal email (Kline to client) | CC: Richard Litman | IMG_0657, IMG_1560, IMG_1705 |
| Date | Document | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Aug 20, 2025 | BHC Management TM SN 99034636 -- Notice of Publication | IMG_0671, IMG_0676, IMG_1648, IMG_1682 |
| Aug 26, 2025 | USPTO trademark notification CC'd to rlitman@nathlaw.com | Finding #40 |
| Date | Sender | Content | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 17, 2025 | Lev Dvorkin (levd@zahav.net.il) | "Final Office Action" complaint TO rlitman@nathlaw.com | IMG_0677, IMG_1684, IMG_1685 |
| Sep 18, 2025 | Lev Dvorkin | "solely because Richard Litman" letter TO Goldberg, CC rlitman@nathlaw.com | IMG_0749 |
| Date | Evidence | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Aug 22-23, 2025 | Google still indexes nathlaw.com with Litman's name ("Retired") | IMG_0564, IMG_1609 |
| Aug 23, 2025 | Wayback capture shows bio page still as "PATENT ATTORNEY" | IMG_0625, IMG_1653, IMG_1666 |
Implication: At least 4 independent data points confirm rlitman@nathlaw.com remained operational (or at minimum, was still listed as the contact address) for 2+ months after the supposed elimination. The email elimination was either (a) incomplete, (b) reversed, or (c) Litman's name continued to be displayed as a contact without his ability to receive mail.
| Date | Client | Amount | Key Details | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 21, 2018 | KISR | $48,515 | Statement of account, BOA trust acct #003926278751 | IMG_1232 |
| Apr 16, 2025 | UAEU | $906 | Annuity fees, BOA trust acct, SWIFT: BOFAUS3N | IMG_1406 |
| Jul 7, 2025 | KSU | $6,500 | PCT application, Goldberg signed, BOA trust acct confirmed | IMG_0536, IMG_1394, IMG_1567 |
| Date | Amount | Route | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 6, 2023 | $1,437,568 | KSU wire to NGM | IMG_0732 |
| Jul 7, 2025 | $500 | Alinma Bank (Saudi) to Eagle Bank acct ****3796 (Nath Associates PLLC) | IMG_1427 |
| Date | Speaker | Admission | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 5-8, 2021 | Goldberg | "$49,085.17" owed to Litman; "the amounts we owe to you" | IMG_0744, IMG_0747 |
| Mar 5, 2021 | Goldberg | "We appreciate your working with us on cashflow issues" | IMG_0747 |
| Mar 9, 2021 | Meyer | "multi-million dollar receivable" (KSU); bank concerns | IMG_0741 |
| Mar 9, 2021 | Meyer | "we are happy to put it aside in a trust account" | IMG_0741 |
| Jun 11, 2025 | Goldberg | "For KFU, you should clearly receive your percentage" | IMG_1417 |
| Jun 11, 2025 | Goldberg | "many of them [trust ledgers] are blank" | IMG_1417 |
| Date | Document | Key Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 15, 2023 | Kadasa filing instruction | Attachments include "RCL Percentage from 06.01.2023," trust registers, WIP billing | IMG_1547 |
| Jun 16, 2025 | Litman to Goldberg | Client renumbering scheme: alternate numbers starting with "1", "3", "5" bypass allocation | IMG_1414 |
| Jun 16, 2025 | Litman to Goldberg | "US Client Fee Summary" for July 2023-June 2025 | IMG_1413 |
| Jun 19, 2025 | Litman to Schaefer/Goldberg | $35,120 in KFU invoices paid but allocation missing | IMG_1411 |
Eleven consecutive daily work assignment emails documenting uninterrupted patent prosecution on Litman-originated dockets (32xxx, 33xxx series) post-termination:
| Date | Dockets | Notable Items | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 18, 2025 | 6 items | THREE abandonments (33150.43U, 33110.48U, 33125.42A) | IMG_1455 |
| Jun 20, 2025 | 3 items | Issue fee, office action response | IMG_1454 |
| Jun 23, 2025 | 5 items | FOUR new patent applications (33044 series) | IMG_1452 |
| Jun 24, 2025 | 4 items | New client (Docket 201081, "Nick handling") | IMG_1449 |
| Jun 25, 2025 | 2 items | POA filed with assignment (32715.79X) -- post-termination | IMG_1447, IMG_1448 |
| Jun 27, 2025 | 1 item | Maintenance fee instruction | IMG_1444, IMG_1445 |
| Jul 1, 2025 | 2 items | New CIP application (KISR series) | IMG_1441 |
| Jul 2, 2025 | 2 items | ONE abandonment (33120.42A: "Do NOT respond; allow case to be abandoned") | IMG_1440 |
| Jul 3, 2025 | 8 items | Office action responses, maintenance fees, declarations | IMG_1438 |
| Jul 7, 2025 | 9 items | Multiple responses, new applications, name correction | IMG_1437 |
| # | Client | Date | Key Quote | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Thomas Bennington (MaxPowerAero) | Jul 3, 2025 | "a customer of Richard Litman's from way back...I thought the world of Mr. Litman" | IMG_1552 |
| 2 | Lev Dvorkin (Israel) | Sep 18, 2025 | "solely for the reason that Mr. Richard Litman works with you...I extended this trust to the firm...Judging by recent events, I made a mistake" | IMG_0749 |
| 3 | Lynn Odland (Dakota AG Innovations) | Oct 8, 2024 | "Our experience with The Litman Law office was such that we are not interested in looking elsewhere" | IMG_1565, IMG_1630 |
| 4 | Julia Stolyarova (FCCA AAA) | Aug 4, 2025 | Prospective TM client reaching out to Litman by name on LinkedIn, asking for a quote | IMG_0447 |
| Date | Evidence | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Oct 9, 2024 | Litman replies to Lynn Odland from rlitman@nathlaw.com | IMG_1565 |
| Aug 4, 2025 | Litman refers Julia Stolyarova to Howard Kline at NGM | IMG_0447 |
| Evidence | Source |
|---|---|
| DDI (Dasman Diabetes Institute, Kuwait) -- Goldberg in group photo | IMG_0420 |
KACST (King Abdulaziz City for Science and Technology, Saudi Arabia) inquired through nathlaw.com contact form while Litman was still listed as "PATENT ATTORNEY." Howard Kline forwarded to Goldberg and Martha Long. (IMG_1555)
| Statement | Source |
|---|---|
| "Our deal was for NGM to buy my practice" -- practice SALE, not employment | IMG_0742 |
| "subject to 90 day notice by either party, death or disqualification to practice law" -- disability NOT listed as termination trigger | IMG_0742 |
| "$25,000/month as a W-2 employee as an advance, trued up quarterly per contract" | IMG_0742 |
| "the 80% due NGM" -- confirms 80/20 split | IMG_0746 |
| "what's due me... as agreed for purchase of the practice" | IMG_0745 |
| Statement | Source |
|---|---|
| "my strong preference is that we keep this between you and I" | IMG_0736 |
| "there is no reason to share more with people than they need to know" | IMG_0736 |
| Re Middle East clients: "we have not been saying anything, nor do I think we should" | IMG_0737 |
| "There is absolutely no need to give our clients any (unjustified) reason to worry about our performance or capabilities" | IMG_0737 |
| Statement | Source |
|---|---|
| "We are in agreement that we need to define our relationship during the 5-year tail of the agreement" | IMG_0741 |
| "if you do not want the money now, we are happy to put it aside in a trust account" | IMG_0741 |
Referenced across multiple screenshots -- Litman demanded removal from nathlaw.com website. NGM responded by adding "Retired" around June 25 but did NOT remove the page, photo, or biography.
| Key Term | Detail | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Agreement terminated | June 15, 2025 | IMG_1329, IMG_1402 |
| Benefits cut | June 30, 2025 | IMG_1329, IMG_1402 |
| Email access promised | Until August 30, 2025 "as a courtesy" | IMG_1329, IMG_1402 |
| Email actually eliminated | July 18, 2025 (43 days early) | IMG_0727, IMG_1276 |
Text messages on the day of elimination: - Litman: "My personal emails have been eliminated from litman@4patent.com and the Nath law account. Is that something you can correct?" - Goldberg: "It should be. Let me find out from IT what happened" - Litman: "Same with NathLaw.com. This whole thing is really affecting me." Source: IMG_0727, IMG_1276
| IMG # | Category | Date | Description | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0109 | Printed email | Apr 21, 2017 | Goldberg-Lafave re NGM addresses; Goldberg home = 2430 20th St NW DC | MEDIUM |
| 0386 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | "nathlaw.com and litman" -- "RICHARD C. LITMAN, PATENT ATTORNEY, Retired" (Jun 25, 2025) | HIGH |
| 0388 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | Page 2 results -- About Us, Apley/Muratori bios ref "Litman Law Offices," RocketReach "Senior Counsel" | MEDIUM |
| 0393 | USPTO TEAS | Jul 8, 2025 | REJUVEMAX TM Sec 8/9 -- Litman as attorney of record (filed Dec 12, 2022) | HIGH |
| 0394 | USPTO TEAS | Jul 8, 2025 | REJUVEMAX continuation -- correspondence info lists Litman | HIGH |
| 0395 | USPTO TEAS | Jul 8, 2025 | REJUVEMAX continuation -- Litman as lead attorney, Goldberg/Meyer/Kline/Harkins additional | HIGH |
| 0396 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | Sitemap Jan 2022 lists Litman in TM dept; MapQuest "Litman Law Ltd" at NGM address | MEDIUM |
| 0397 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | Bio page "Retired" (Jun 25); Commercialization page "PATENT ATTORNEY" (no Retired, Jun 14, 2024) | HIGH |
| 0403 | USPTO TSDR | Jul 8, 2025 | Active TM showing rlitman@nathlaw.com + efile@4patent.com as correspondent (Mar 24, 2025) | HIGH |
| 0417 | Oct 10, 2024 | Teri Schweiss to Goldberg/Long, CC kfu@4patent.com -- "NO REMINDER from KFU" | MEDIUM | |
| 0418 | Oct 10, 2024 | Martha Long to Goldberg/Schweiss, CC kfu@4patent.com -- originating "NO REMINDER" email | MEDIUM | |
| 0420 | Website/image | Jul 14, 2025 | DDI group photo with Goldberg visiting Dasman Diabetes Institute in Kuwait | MEDIUM |
| 0422 | Website | Jul 14, 2025 | www.litmanlaw.com "Arabic IP Practice" page still live | HIGH |
| 0423 | Google search | Jul 14, 2025 | Success.ai "Senior Counsel," nathlaw.com Commercialization page, Florida Bar, TTABVUE | HIGH |
| 0424 | Google search | Jul 14, 2025 | Florida Bar shows Litman at Brooklyn address with litman@4patent.com email | HIGH |
| 0425 | Google search | Jul 14, 2025 | PatentBuddy, Apley bio, Success.ai results | MEDIUM |
| 0436 | Google search | Jul 19, 2025 | Florida Bar, nathlaw.com, LinkedIn "Senior Counsel @ NGM, Brooklyn" | MEDIUM |
| 0438 | Google search | Jul 19, 2025 | KSU faculty page hosting patent with Litman as attorney | MEDIUM |
| 0444 | Google search | Jul 21, 2025 | Growjo, RocketReach, Datanyze all list Litman as "Senior Counsel" -- 3 days post-elimination | MEDIUM |
| 0447 | LinkedIn DM | Aug 4, 2025 | Julia Stolyarova -- prospective TM client contacts Litman by name, asks for quote | HIGH |
| IMG # | Category | Date | Description | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0526 | Jul 14, 2025 | Kline to SPI Coatings client, CC rlitman@ -- TM declaration of use due | HIGH | |
| 0536 | Invoice | Jul 7, 2025 | KSU $6,500 PCT invoice, Goldberg signed, BOA trust acct | HIGH |
| 0538 | Google search | ~Jul 2025 | "Retired" first appears in Google index (Jun 25, 2025 date) | HIGH |
| 0542 | Client letter | Jul 24, 2025 | Hashtag Sports TM letter signed "Richard C. Litman / Howard W. Kline" -- post-elimination | HIGH |
| 0543 | Jul 24, 2025 | Kline emails Hashtag Sports client, CC rlitman@ -- post-elimination | HIGH | |
| 0544 | Google search | Aug 22, 2025 | KSU patent, nathlaw.com Commercialization page in results | MEDIUM |
| 0545 | Wayback | Apr 28, 2025 | /professionals/ -- Litman as "PATENT ATTORNEY" | HIGH |
| 0546 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ -- top of bio, "PATENT ATTORNEY" (no Retired) | HIGH |
| 0547 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ -- bottom of bio, credentials, Copyright 2025 | HIGH |
| 0548 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ -- middle, "is a Patent Attorney" (present tense) | HIGH |
| 0549 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | Duplicate of 0546 | LOW |
| 0550 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | Duplicate of 0548 | LOW |
| 0551 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | Duplicate of 0547 | LOW |
| 0555 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | Duplicate, screenshotted Aug 23 -- chain of custody | LOW |
| 0556 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | Duplicate, screenshotted Aug 23 | LOW |
| 0557 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | Duplicate, screenshotted Sep 2 | LOW |
| 0558 | Wayback | Apr 28, 2025 | Duplicate of 0545, screenshotted Sep 2 | LOW |
| 0560 | Google search | Jul 19, 2025 | Tighter crop of 0544 | LOW |
| 0561 | Google search | Jul 19, 2025 | Same in crop/edit mode | LOW |
| 0562 | Client letter | Jul 24, 2025 | Duplicate of 0542 -- Hashtag Sports letter | LOW |
| 0564 | Google search | Aug 22, 2025 | "Retired" in Google results | HIGH |
| 0565 | Google search | Aug 22, 2025 | Duplicate of 0564 | LOW |
| 0568 | Google search | Aug 21, 2025 | Original screenshot from which 0544/0560 are crops | MEDIUM |
| 0581 | Jul 14, 2025 | Duplicate of 0526 -- SPI Coatings | LOW | |
| 0596 | Email chain | Apr 4, 2023 | KSU trust transfer $2,290, Goldberg approves from Brooklyn, CC ksu@4patent.com | HIGH |
| 0600 | Wayback | Feb 19, 2025 | /electrical-mechanical-and-chemical-engineering-departments/ -- Litman listed | HIGH |
| 0601 | Wayback | Feb 19, 2025 | /trademarks-and-copyrights-department/ -- Litman SOLE listing | HIGH |
| 0602 | Wayback | Feb 19, 2025 | Duplicate of 0600 (different scroll) | LOW |
| 0603 | Wayback | Apr 28, 2025 | /commercialization-and-licensing/ -- Litman alongside LaFave | HIGH |
| 0604 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | /electrical-mechanical-and-chemical-engineering-departments/ -- still listed post-demand | HIGH |
| IMG # | Category | Date | Description | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0616 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | /electrical-mechanical/ dept page -- Litman as "PATENT ATTORNEY" | HIGH |
| 0621 | Jul 7, 2025 | Nicola Pizza TM -- Angela Berry approves, Litman CC'd | HIGH | |
| 0622 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | nathlaw.com, litmanlaw.com, Experience.com, TTABVUE results | HIGH |
| 0625 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ -- full bio, "PATENT ATTORNEY" (no Retired) | HIGH |
| 0627 | Client letter | Jul 24, 2025 | Hashtag Sports letter -- "Richard C. Litman / Howard W. Kline" | HIGH |
| 0628 | Google search | Aug 22, 2025 | "Retired" still showing in Google results | MEDIUM |
| 0645 | Apr 4, 2023 | Goldberg approves KSU transfer from Brooklyn, CC ksu@4patent.com, "Green Patent Guy" | HIGH | |
| 0651 | Jul 14, 2025 | Kline to SPI Coatings, CC rlitman@ | HIGH | |
| 0654 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | /professionals/ -- Litman photo and title visible | HIGH |
| 0656 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | Duplicate of 0622 | LOW |
| 0657 | Jul 25, 2025 | Kline to "James" re QUICK BIB TM renewal, CC Litman -- 7 days post-elimination | HIGH | |
| 0665 | Google search | Jul 21, 2025 | Growjo, RocketReach, Datanyze -- "Senior Counsel" | MEDIUM |
| 0671 | USPTO email | Aug 20, 2025 | BHC Management SN 99034636 -- official notice TO Richard Litman post-elimination | HIGH |
| 0673 | Google search | Jul 8/Sep 15 | Duplicate of 0622 | LOW |
| 0676 | USPTO email | Aug 20, 2025 | BHC Management -- cropped view, same as 0671 | LOW |
| 0677 | Sep 17, 2025 | Dvorkin to Litman -- 4 filing errors, "$20,000 for what?" | HIGH | |
| 0678 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | Duplicate of 0616 | LOW |
| 0727 | Text messages | Jul 17-19, 2025 | Email elimination exchange + KFU Trust Flow PDF | HIGH |
| 0732 | Email/Gmail | Mar 6, 2023 | $1,437,568 KSU wire transfer discussion | HIGH |
| 0733 | Dec 19, 2022 | Goldberg to KSU re payments, CC Litman, "Green Patent Guy" from Brooklyn | MEDIUM | |
| 0734 | Dec 19, 2022 | Duplicate of 0733 (viewed Jul 20, 2025 -- evidence preservation) | LOW | |
| 0736 | Email thread | Jun 7-8, 2020 | Goldberg: disability concealment -- "keep this between you and I" | HIGH |
| 0737 | Email thread | Jun 8, 2020 | Goldberg: Middle East clients -- "no reason to share more than they need to know" | HIGH |
| 0738 | Email thread | Jun 7-8, 2020 | Duplicate of 0736 | LOW |
| 0740 | Email thread | Jun 7, 2020 | Personal relationship context -- "How is Jerry? You?" | LOW |
| 0741 | Email thread | Mar 9, 2021 | Meyer: "5-year tail," trust account offer, "multi-million dollar receivable" | HIGH |
| 0742 | Email thread | Mar 9, 2021 | Litman: "Our deal was for NGM to buy my practice," $25K/month, disability NOT termination trigger | HIGH |
| 0744 | Email thread | Mar 8, 2021 | Goldberg: "the amounts we owe to you," trust account offer | HIGH |
| 0745 | Email thread | Mar 5, 2021 | Litman: "what's due me...as agreed for purchase of the practice," interest-free loan offer | HIGH |
| 0746 | Email thread | Mar 5, 2021 | Litman: "the 80% due NGM," financing KSU operations with his own unpaid earnings | HIGH |
| 0747 | Email thread | Mar 5, 2021 | Goldberg: "$49,085.17" owed, "Kim" generated reports, KSU/UAEU/KFU receivables | HIGH |
| 0749 | Sep 18, 2025 | Dvorkin: "solely because Richard Litman," trust extended then regretted | HIGH | |
| 0755 | Jan 18, 2024 | KSU "Non-Spill Test Tube" patent search -- Martha Long, Litman CC'd | MEDIUM |
| IMG # | Category | Date | Description | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1232 | Financial doc | Jun 21, 2018 | KISR statement of account $48,515, confirms BOA trust acct | MEDIUM |
| 1276 | Text message | Jul 18-19, 2025 | "This whole thing is really affecting me" + KFU Trust Flow PDF | HIGH |
| 1297 | Oct 28, 2024 | MaryJane Harper sets up Litman's Soluno login (rlitman@nathlaw.com) | HIGH | |
| 1313 | Jun 20, 2025 | EEZ LLC TM -- Litman CC'd on "Mega Marshmallow" | MEDIUM | |
| 1329 | Letter | ~Jun 2025 | Heba Carter termination letter -- email until Aug 30 "as a courtesy" | HIGH |
| 1391 | Jun 15, 2025 | SACGC outstanding invoices follow-up -- sent on exact SOL date | MEDIUM | |
| 1394 | Invoice | Jul 7, 2025 | KSU PCT $4,500 invoice, NGM letterhead with 4patent.com | HIGH |
| 1402 | Letter | ~Jun 2025 | Heba Carter -- cleaner version of 1329 | HIGH |
| 1406 | Invoice | Apr 16, 2025 | UAEU annuity $906, BOA trust acct, SWIFT code | MEDIUM |
| 1408 | Mar 5, 2021 | Litman proposes CASE Act practice to Goldberg/Meyer | MEDIUM | |
| 1411 | Jun 19, 2025 | $35,120 KFU paid-but-unallocated invoices documented | HIGH | |
| 1413 | Jun 16, 2025 | Litman seeks US client fee reconciliation Jul 2023-Jun 2025 | HIGH | |
| 1414 | Jun 16, 2025 | Client renumbering scheme: "1", "3", "5" numbers bypass allocation | HIGH | |
| 1417 | Jun 11, 2025 | Goldberg KFU admission: "you should clearly receive your percentage" | HIGH | |
| 1418 | Jun 11, 2025 | Litman reviewing trust ledgers -- "most have nothing on them" | HIGH | |
| 1427 | Wire transfer | Jul 7, 2025 | $500 Alinma Bank (Saudi) to Eagle Bank acct -- second bank identified | MEDIUM |
| 1429 | ChatGPT/Archive | Jul 1, 2025 | Archive.today confirms Litman on nathlaw.com through Jul 1 | HIGH |
| 1437 | Martha Long | Jul 7, 2025 | 9 dockets -- work for today | MEDIUM |
| 1438 | Martha Long | Jul 3, 2025 | 8 dockets including office action responses | MEDIUM |
| 1440 | Martha Long | Jul 2, 2025 | "Do NOT respond; allow case to be abandoned" (33120.42A) | HIGH |
| 1441 | Martha Long | Jul 1, 2025 | New CIP application (KISR series) | LOW |
| 1444 | Martha Long | Jun 27, 2025 | Maintenance fee instruction | LOW |
| 1445 | Martha Long | Jun 27, 2025 | Duplicate of 1444 with Health Records notification | LOW |
| 1447 | Martha Long | Jun 25, 2025 | POA filed with assignment -- 10 days post-termination | HIGH |
| 1448 | Martha Long | Jun 25, 2025 | Issue fee payment | LOW |
| 1449 | Martha Long | Jun 24, 2025 | New client (201081, "Nick handling") + 3 patent matters | MEDIUM |
| 1452 | Martha Long | Jun 23, 2025 | FOUR new patent applications (33044 series) | MEDIUM |
| 1454 | Martha Long | Jun 20, 2025 | Issue fee, office action, patent search | LOW |
| 1455 | Martha Long | Jun 18, 2025 | THREE abandonments + 3 other actions | HIGH |
| 1462 | Live website | ~Jan 23, 2025 | LIVE nathlaw.com screenshot -- "Richard C. Litman, PATENT ATTORNEY" | HIGH |
| 1466 | ChatGPT/Archive | Jul 1, 2025 | Duplicate of 1429 in Photos app | LOW |
| IMG # | Category | Date | Description | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1501 | Wayback | varies | /commercialization-and-licensing/ -- Litman, Nath, Goldberg, Kline | HIGH |
| 1502 | Wayback | varies | Same page, different capture date | MEDIUM |
| 1503 | Wayback | ~Nov 2024 | Same page, Goldberg photo broken but Litman displayed | MEDIUM |
| 1547 | Jun 15, 2023 | Kadasa/KFU filing with "RCL Percentage" and trust register attachments | HIGH | |
| 1551 | Jul 7, 2025 | Nicola Pizza "Yes, please proceed" -- Litman CC'd | HIGH | |
| 1552 | Contact form | Jul 3, 2025 | Thomas Bennington: "customer of Richard Litman's from way back" | HIGH |
| 1555 | Contact form | Jun 26, 2025 | KACST (Saudi) inquiry through nathlaw.com | MEDIUM |
| 1556 | Jun 18, 2025 | EZ TRUCK TM office action -- Litman CC'd (rlitman@nathlaw.com) | HIGH | |
| 1559 | Google search | Jul 19, 2025 | nathlaw.com Commercialization "Richard C. Litman PATENT ATTORNEY" | HIGH |
| 1560 | Jul 25, 2025 | QUICK BIB TM renewal -- Litman CC'd, 7 days post-elimination | HIGH | |
| 1560 Copy | Jul 25, 2025 | Duplicate of 1560 | LOW | |
| 1565 | Oct 8-9, 2024 | Dakota AG / Odland: "The Litman Law office" -- Litman replies | HIGH | |
| 1567 | Invoice | Jul 7, 2025 | KSU $6,500 PCT with wire details (BOA confirmed) | HIGH |
| 1568 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | "Retired" in results (Jun 25, 2025); litmanlaw.com still active | HIGH |
| 1574 | Apr 4, 2023 | KSU trust transfer $2,290 -- Goldberg from Brooklyn, ksu@4patent.com | HIGH | |
| 1589 | Google search | Aug 21, 2025 | Duplicate/variant of 1559 | LOW |
| 1609 | Google search | Aug 22, 2025 | "Retired" persisting in Google results | MEDIUM |
| 1612 | Client letter | Jul 24, 2025 | Hashtag Sports -- "Richard C. Litman / Howard W. Kline" post-elimination | HIGH |
| 1613 | Google search | Jul 19, 2025 | Duplicate of 1559 in editing mode | LOW |
| 1614 | Google search | Jul 19, 2025 | Duplicate of 1559 | LOW |
| 1615 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ full bio page | HIGH |
| 1619 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ education/credentials section | HIGH |
| 1624 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ bottom -- Copyright 2025, bar admissions | HIGH |
| 1625 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ same as 1615 | LOW |
| 1626 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ widest view with browser chrome, "Pay Your Invoice" | HIGH |
| 1627 | Google search | Aug 22, 2025 | KSU patent + nathlaw.com in results | MEDIUM |
| 1628 | Jul 24, 2025 | Kline to Hashtag Sports client, CC rlitman@ -- post-elimination | HIGH | |
| 1629 | Client letter | Jul 24, 2025 | Cleaner version of 1612 -- Hashtag Sports | MEDIUM |
| 1630 | Oct 8-9, 2024 | Duplicate of 1565 -- Dakota AG | LOW | |
| 1631 | Jul 7, 2025 | Duplicate of 1551 -- Nicola Pizza | LOW | |
| 1635 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | 7+ sources showing Litman: nathlaw.com "Retired," Commercialization page, Experience.com, Sitemap, USPTO TEAS, TTABVUE | HIGH |
| IMG # | Category | Date | Description | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1648 | USPTO email | Aug 20, 2025 | BHC Management SN 99034636 -- official notice TO Richard Litman | HIGH |
| 1652 | USPTO TSDR | Sep 15, 2025 | Marco Foam TM -- Litman as "prior attorney" | MEDIUM |
| 1653 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | /professionals/ -- "RICHARD C. LITMAN, PATENT ATTORNEY" (crop tool) | HIGH |
| 1656 | Jul 14, 2025 | Kline to SPI Coatings, CC rlitman@ | HIGH | |
| 1665 | Client letter | Jul 24, 2025 | Hashtag Sports -- "Richard C. Litman / Howard W. Kline" | HIGH |
| 1666 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ -- full bio, "is a Patent Attorney" (present tense) | HIGH |
| 1670 | Wayback | varies | /electrical-mechanical/ dept -- Litman ONLY attorney among 4 agents + 1 advisor | HIGH |
| 1673 | Wayback | varies | Duplicate of 1670 in editing mode | LOW |
| 1674 | Client letter | Jul 24, 2025 | Hashtag Sports -- clean full view | MEDIUM |
| 1677 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ bottom -- credentials, Copyright 2023, bar admissions | HIGH |
| 1682 | USPTO email | Aug 20, 2025 | Duplicate of 1648 -- BHC Management | LOW |
| 1684 | Sep 17, 2025 | Dvorkin to rlitman@ -- 4 filing errors, "$20K for what?" (unredacted) | HIGH | |
| 1685 | Sep 17, 2025 | Duplicate of 1684 | LOW | |
| 1689 | Client letter | Jul 24, 2025 | Duplicate of 1665 -- Hashtag Sports | LOW |
| 1690 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | /richard-c-litman/ -- timeline showing 10 captures | MEDIUM |
| 1693 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | nathlaw.com "Retired" (Jun 25), litmanlaw.com, Commercialization page, Experience, Sitemap, USPTO | HIGH |
| 1694 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | Duplicate of 1693 | LOW |
| 1695 | Wayback | Jun 21, 2025 | Duplicate of 1690 | LOW |
| 1702 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | Rotated/landscape duplicate of 1677 | LOW |
| 1703 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | Photo of screen, alternate angle of 1666 | LOW |
| 1704 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | Clean view of bio -- exhibit quality | HIGH |
| 1705 | Jul 25, 2025 | QUICK BIB TM renewal, CC Litman -- 7 days post-elimination | HIGH | |
| 1707 | Sep 17, 2025 | Dvorkin (REDACTED/highlighted for exhibit) | MEDIUM | |
| 1711 | Client letter | Jul 24, 2025 | Hashtag Sports (REDACTED/highlighted for exhibit) | MEDIUM |
| 1712 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | Duplicate of 1693 | LOW |
| 1715 | Sep 17, 2025 | Dvorkin (REDACTED, different highlight pattern) | LOW | |
| 1721 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | Duplicate of 1693 | LOW |
| 1722 | Google search | Jul 8, 2025 | Best quality version of 1693 -- exhibit quality | HIGH |
| 1723 | Wayback (annotated) | Jun 21, 2025 | Yellow arrows pointing to date and Litman's name | HIGH |
| 1724 | Wayback | Aug 23, 2025 | Alternate angle of 1704 | LOW |
| Screenshot 2025-09-09 | Wayback | Sep 9, 2025 | Desktop browser, full bio page -- latest-dated screenshot | HIGH |
| Rating | Count |
|---|---|
| HIGH | ~80 |
| MEDIUM | ~40 |
| LOW | ~56 |
Unique (deduplicated) evidence items: ~95 Duplicates/alternate captures: ~81
| Photo | Content | Recommended Use |
|---|---|---|
| IMG_1704 | Wayback Aug 23, 2025 -- Litman bio, clean, "PATENT ATTORNEY" | Website name-use post-demand |
| IMG_1677 | Wayback Aug 23, 2025 -- bio bottom (credentials, Copyright 2025) | Complete bio evidence |
| Screenshot 2025-09-09 | Wayback full bio -- desktop, Sept 9, 2025 | Latest-dated screenshot |
| IMG_1674 | Hashtag Sports letter Jul 24, 2025, clean view | Post-elimination client letter |
| IMG_1707 | Dvorkin email (redacted/highlighted) | rlitman@ active Sept 2025 |
| IMG_1722 | Google results "Retired" (best quality) | Retired designation evidence |
| IMG_1723 | Wayback with yellow arrows (annotated) | Annotated timeline exhibit |
| IMG_1670 | Department page -- Litman only attorney | Department prominence |
| IMG_1648 | USPTO BHC notification Aug 20, 2025 | Post-elimination USPTO |
| IMG_0601 | TM dept page -- Litman SOLE listing | Trademarks-specific evidence |
| IMG_1462 | Live nathlaw.com screenshot | Live website vs. Wayback |
| IMG_1552 | Bennington contact form | Goodwill -- "thought the world of Mr. Litman" |
| IMG_0749 | Dvorkin "solely because" full letter | Goodwill -- strongest statement |
| IMG_0744 | Goldberg: "amounts we owe to you" | Party admission of debt |
| IMG_0747 | Goldberg: "$49,085.17" | Quantified admission |
| IMG_0742 | Litman: "NGM to buy my practice" | Agreement characterization |
| IMG_0746 | Litman: "the 80% due NGM" | 20% formula confirmation |
This memo is the authoritative reference for all 176 nathlaw photos. For individual photo details, see the 6 batch files.