Pages 601–783 of the Meyer Emails PDF consist almost entirely of two email threads, both relating to King Saud University (KSU) patent work and payment collection. The same thread is rendered multiple times in different email client formats (plain text, rich HTML, Outlook MSG), creating apparent page volume that is actually the same substantive content repeated 4–5 times in different renderings.
Meyer's role in these pages: Meyer (JMeyer@Nathlaw.com) is CC'd on all KSU correspondence but does NOT author any emails in this section. All substantive communications are from Joshua Goldberg, Martha Long, or KSU contacts (Dr. Thamer Albahkali, Hany Hassan Aly). Meyer is a silent participant — his inclusion on the CC line is itself the evidence: he was fully aware of all KSU financial matters, Litman's continued involvement, and the revenue flows.
Bates: RL_6632–RL_6653 (first rendering), repeated at RL_6672–RL_6714, RL_6747–RL_6814
Litman CC'd on ALL KSU correspondence (Sept 2022–Dec 2022) — Every single email in this thread includes rlitman@nathlaw.com on the CC line. This is 2+ years post-SOL cutoff (6/15/2020) and post-arbitration (6/14/2023 not yet occurred). The continued inclusion proves Litman was being held out as involved in KSU work.
ksu@4patent.com alias active throughout — Every email CCs the ksu@4patent.com distribution alias, confirming NGM routed KSU correspondence through Litman's personal domain (4patent.com) throughout 2022. Supports Finding #46 (4patent.com client alias infrastructure).
$1.2M+ KSU receivable acknowledged by Goldberg — Direct evidence of the scale of the KSU relationship. This receivable was being managed using Litman's name on all correspondence.
"Old wire information" vs "new (NGM) wire information" — Martha Long's Sept 27, 2022 email asks KSU whether invoices need to be "updated with the new (NGM) wire information" — indicating a banking transition from B&P/Litman-era wire instructions to NGM wire instructions. This is relevant to the Freedom Bank / bank account proliferation issue.
Meyer fully aware of KSU financial situation — Meyer is CC'd on every email in this chain. He cannot claim ignorance of KSU revenue, payment patterns, or Litman's continued involvement.
Bates: RL_6715–RL_6728
Bates: RL_6725–6726 - From: Intellectual Property and Technology Licensing Program (iptl@KSU.EDU.SA) - To: Goldberg, Thamer, Martha Long - CC: ksu@4patent.com, Jerry Meyer, Richard Litman - Content: Wire transfer confirmation for $1,437,568.00. KSU notes remaining $129,680.00 will be wired within 60 days when new budget executes. Instructs NGM to: 1. File applications on hold at USPTO 2. File applications with signed declarations 3. Prepare unprepared application drafts 4. Pay maintenance fees 5. Resume prosecution activities
ADMISSION: This is the same $1,437,568 KSU wire referenced in Finding #89 (Exhibit J). The email chain confirms Meyer was CC'd on the wire notification and all follow-up discussions about how to allocate the money.
Bates: RL_6723–6725 - Goldberg sends KSU a comprehensive breakdown of 6 categories of outstanding work - Proposes Zoom meeting to discuss priorities - CC: Meyer, Litman
Bates: RL_6720–6721 - From: Dr. Thamer - Content: References Zoom meeting. Instructs NGM to start filing cases in tables 1-5, pay maintenance fees. Confirms: - "+$129,000 wire will be within 2 months" - "+$30,000 is ready in our fund" - "$1 Million budget assigned for us this year"
ADMISSION: KSU committed $1M+ in new work for 2023 — revenue flowing through a client relationship originated by Litman.
Bates: RL_6716–6717 - From: Joshua Goldberg - To: Richard Litman - Subject: RE: wire transfer with amount ($1,437,568.00) - Key quote: "Regardless of what was done previously, moving forward I want to pay you based on collected monies as the work is completed (not for funds held in trust for work to be completed), or for work previously completed, with the understanding that we will put a pause on further work once the receivable gets too high until payment is made."
ADMISSIONS in this email: 1. Goldberg explicitly acknowledges he owes Litman payment on KSU collections — "I want to pay you based on collected monies" 2. Confirms revenue-sharing arrangement persists post-SOL — This is February 2023, nearly 3 years after the 6/15/2020 "termination" 3. Goldberg will not cap KSU receivable above $500,000 — "it is hard for me to imagine permitting it to exceed $500,000" 4. Goldberg wants to restrict payment to "collected monies" vs trust funds — attempts to narrow the 20% formula to exclude money held in trust 5. "Contrary to your lawyer's position about deducting the previously unpaid invoices from KSU from what you owe me" — reveals Goldberg's arbitration lawyer was arguing KSU unpaid invoices should offset Litman's share. Litman pushes back.
Bates: RL_6716–6718 - From: Richard Litman - To: Joshua Goldberg - Subject: RE: wire transfer with amount ($1,437,568.00) - Key quotes: - "This is a pivotal call." - "With accurate trust account ledgers for each KSU matter, and an understanding of the time sensitivity of each of these matters, consider proposing that Dr. Thamer give permission for the law firm to shift money from trust accounts for lower in priority to the highest priority matters" - "It could be the spring board for new work in 2023 - if you want it. He said they had a $1 million budget for 2023." - "Contrary to your lawyer's position about deducting the previously unpaid invoices from KSU from what you owe me, I will be glad to help here if I will not be blamed if KSU doesn't pay within acceptable times." - "It is for the firm to make it easy for KSU to pay. I think Thamer said there is a limit of about $125K per wire." - "My suggestion is that the firm provide real time accounting for KSU, or at least provide each week an accounting for all matters" - "We want the weekly report to be something he looks forward to getting, and payments on track like with Sabah Center."
ADMISSIONS / EVIDENCE: 1. Litman is ACTIVELY ADVISING on KSU client strategy — 2.5+ years post-"termination," providing detailed client management advice including trust account strategy, payment frequency, reporting cadence, and priority setting 2. References "Sabah Center" — another Litman-originated Middle East institutional client (Sabah Al Ahmad Center), used as a model for KSU payment management 3. "Contrary to your lawyer's position about deducting... from what you owe me" — Litman explicitly states Goldberg owes him money. The arbitration lawyer was trying to offset KSU uncollected invoices against Litman's share. 4. Litman has detailed knowledge of KSU internal workings — knows about $125K per-wire limit, $1M budget, Dr. Thamer's role — consistent with decades of relationship building 5. Destroys "disability = death" defense — Litman is providing sophisticated client management advice, not incapacitated
| Amount | Context | Bates |
|---|---|---|
| $609,170.00 | KSU wires received Sept 21, 2022 (5 transfers) | RL_6652/6709 |
| $1,200,000+ | KSU outstanding receivable (as of Sept 2022) | RL_6648 |
| $1,437,568.00 | KSU wire transfer Dec 22, 2022 | RL_6725 |
| $129,680.00 | Additional KSU wire promised within 60 days | RL_6726 |
| $30,000 | Ready KSU funds from university fund | RL_6720 |
| $1,000,000 | KSU 2023 budget for NGM patent work | RL_6720 |
| $500,000 | Goldberg's stated cap on KSU receivable | RL_6716 |
| $1,350/each | Petition to reinstate expired maintenance fees | RL_6643 |
| $125,000 | Per-wire limit for KSU transfers (per Litman) | RL_6718 |
Total KSU revenue in this 3-month window alone: $2,046,738+ ($609K + $1,437K)
| Finding | Connection |
|---|---|
| Finding #47 (Litman directing KFU Oct 2024) | This thread proves the pattern started at least by Feb 2023 — Litman was actively advising on Middle East clients throughout the post-SOL period |
| Finding #51 (KFU $9.89M unallocated) | The $1.4M KSU wire is the same wire referenced in Exhibit J. The $129,680 promised "within 60 days" matches exactly the amount Goldberg later promised Litman (Finding #89) |
| Finding #46 (4patent.com aliases) | ksu@4patent.com active on every email, confirming client-alias infrastructure |
| Finding #89 (Exhibit J — $1,437,568 wire) | This thread provides the FULL context around Exhibit J: it was not just a wire receipt but part of a months-long collection effort where both Litman and Meyer were actively involved |
| Finding #99 (NGM bank accounts) | Martha Long's reference to "old wire information" vs "new (NGM) wire information" documents the banking transition |
| Finding #28 (Dakota AG) | Litman references "Sabah Center" as a model payment client, adding a sixth institutional client (alongside KFU, KSU, UAEU, KNPC, Dakota AG) where Litman's personal relationships drove collections |
| Finding #102 (KSU $129,680 through Freedom Bank) | The $129,680 promised in this thread on Jan 13, 2023 is the EXACT amount later routed through Freedom Bank on May 8, 2024 — traced in NGM_Litman_Workup.xlsx row 117,345 |
Meyer does not write a single email in pages 601-783, yet he is CC'd on every single one. This establishes him as a fully informed partner who: - Knew KSU owed $1.2M+ and received $2M+ in late 2022 - Knew Litman was actively advising on client management strategy - Knew Goldberg acknowledged payment obligations to Litman - Knew the ksu@4patent.com alias was being used for all client correspondence
Every email in this thread includes Litman (rlitman@nathlaw.com) as a participant. The KSU contacts are not told Litman has any reduced role — he is presented as an active member of the team receiving and advising on $2M+ in client work.
The $129,680 amount appears in this thread (Jan 13, 2023, promised by KSU within 60 days), in Goldberg's March 6, 2023 promise to Litman (Finding #89), and in the NGM_Litman_Workup.xlsx as a Freedom Bank wire on May 8, 2024 (Finding #102). This is a traceable dollar amount connecting KSU revenue to the Freedom Bank trust account.
The same KSU thread (Sept 21 – Dec 19, 2022) appears at least 5 times in different rendering formats across pages 601-783. This suggests the PDF was compiled by collecting the same email thread from multiple mailboxes or export formats — consistent with a comprehensive discovery production.
Analysis completed 2026-04-15. Bates range: RL_6632–RL_6814. Pages 601–783 of 0008- Meyer Emails (RL_6032-6814).pdf