Source: evidence/aaa_lawsuit_package_20250728/
Total files: 352
Package date: July 28, 2025 (uncle-assembled working corpus, pre-litigation-filing snapshot)
Cataloged: 2026-04-10
| Type | Count |
|---|---|
| 190 | |
| DOCX | 94 |
| XLSX | 27 |
| PNG | 18 |
| CSV | 6 |
| JPG/JPEG | 5 |
| ZIP | 3 |
| EML | 1 |
| TIF | 1 |
| Unnamed/stub (MISC, OG Trust Ledger) | ~7 |
| Folder | Files |
|---|---|
| EXHBITS (incl. Context subfolder) | 64 |
| TRUST LEDGERS (incl. Jan 2023 Matters) | 54 |
| Federal Complaint (incl. Framework, To Serve, Discovery) | 25 |
| State - Complaint (all 10 Unicode conflict variants combined) | 71 |
| Motion for Accounting - State Court | 17 |
| LEGAL FRAMEWORK | 15 |
| Arbitration | 14 |
| MISC | 14 |
| OG ACOUNTING FROM GRACE SPLIT UP | 12 |
| MONEY PAID TO ME | 11 |
| Demand Letter | 10 |
| Context July 19th 2025 | 9 |
| AAA - master context | 8 |
| ART (DANIEL'S COLLECTION) | 8 |
| Lawyer Letters | 7 |
| All invoices … All dates with AR | 4 |
| Summary Over (Unicode variant) | 4 |
| Top-level loose files | 4 |
Note: The "State - Complaint" tree replicated 10× as Dropbox "Unicode Encoding Conflict" copies — these appear to be sync-collision duplicates of the same working directory, not distinct content. Treat as one logical folder (~71 files, heavy redundancy across v111–v999 drafts).
The "master" submission set. All present as single canonical PDFs:
- 2022.10.17- Demand for Arbitration.pdf — original arbitration demand
- Award - Litman v. NGM, et al..pdf — 6/14/2023 arbitration award
- FEDERAL COMPLAINT v666.pdf + LITMAN vs NATH, Fedral Complaint FINAL.pdf — EDNY 1:25-cv-04048
- NGM Litman Agreement.pdf + NGM Litman Amendment .pdf — 2017 combination + amendment
- RCL COMPLAINT v2...888.pdf — state court working draft
- STATE COURT COMPLAINT - 524343_2025_Richard_C_Litman_v_Joshua_B_Goldberg_SUMMONS___COMPLAINT_1 (FROM COURT).pdf — filed state complaint
- Accompanying AAA - master context.zip (50 MB) sits at root
Six versioned drafts of the 10/17/2022 Demand for Arbitration (v111–v555 + final) in both .docx and .pdf, plus two "DRAFT" predecessor PDFs. Effectively one document, 8 revision states.
NOT legal evidence. Cover art / poster / family photo files (Fight poster 1.pdf, Leprechaun.pdf, Cover Art.jpg, and momma.pdf, three hashes in jpg/pdf/tif for the same artwork). Exclude from legal analysis.
This is the Master Context Package uncle assembled for lawyers on 7/19/2025. High-value bundle:
- Context July 19th 2025.docx/pdf — uncle's narrative context memo
- Award - Litman v. NGM, et al..pdf — arbitration award
- Demand Letter 7.pdf — latest demand letter version
- Formal Response to June 26, 2025 Correspondence...pdf — trust account misconduct response
- Month By Month Payment to Me Breakdown .pdf — the memory-reconstructed $21K–$27K ledger (Finding #49 flagged NOT to file)
- NGM Litman Agreement.pdf + NGM Litman Amendment .pdf
- NGM_Litman_Workup (Lawyers Summary) .xlsx — lawyers' summary workup
Versioned drafts 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7 of the pre-suit demand letter (mix of .docx and .pdf). Also stray 5.docx. One logical document, 6 iterations.
This is the filed exhibit set for the state court complaint / federal complaint. Lettered exhibits:
- Exhibit A — Accounting Discrepancy (two versions: original + V2, both PDF/PNG)
- Exhibit B — Report Grace Sent (Report_20250626_021254.pdf)
- Exhibit C — "RICHARD C. LITMAN – Nath Goldberg Meyer" (proof of name use 2+ years post-2020, "Retired" search as of 7/8/2025)
- Exhibit D — All invoices with AR account summary 6/21/2025 (shows tapering receivables)
- Exhibit E — Text Messages - Joshua Goldberg
- Exhibit F — Use of Richard Litman's name after 2020
- Exhibit G — KSU Issued US Patent w/ Litman as attorney of record
- Exhibit H — KFU Issued US Patent w/ Litman as attorney of record
- Exhibit I — Updated_Originated_Clients_List.pdf
- Exhibit J — Gmail Fwd: wire transfer $1,437,568.00
- Exhibit K — 6/2020 Goldberg emails re confidential status quo until Jerry better
- Exhibit L — NGM March 2021 position: trust account, KSU fees, payment twice/month
- Exhibit M — 9/2022 Goldberg email acknowledging Litman help
- Exhibit N — Registration Certificate - HARDCORE
- Exhibit O — Gmail Fwd: KSU Patent Applications for Filing
- Exhibit P — Gmail Fwd: January numbers
- Exhibit Q — Litman R COBRA SPECIFIC RIGHTS 7/2025
- Exhibit R — Asset Sale Trademark Assignment
- ALL EXHIBITS .pdf — combined binder
Context sheets explaining each exhibit. Pairs of .docx + .pdf for exhibits A, C, D, F/G/H, I, J, K, L, M, N, O/P, Q, R — uncle's annotation of why each exhibit matters. Plus:
- 30011517220031SCIV.PDF — SCIV filing (unknown number)
- Exhbit E - OVERVIEW analysis Exhbit E - Text Messages - Joshua Goldberg.pdf/.docx
- Client & Owner Numbers.xlsx — client number crosswalk
- Client list context.docx
- IMG_0386.PNG retired.pdf — "retired" screenshot
- maybe fradu payment IMG_0429.pdf — suspicious payment screenshot
- Receivables by Client report for RCL June 2025.pdf
- SUS LARGE TRANSACTIONS .pdf — suspect transactions list
- Updated_Originated_Clients_List.csv
EDNY 1:25-cv-04048 drafts + supporting framework:
- Drafts v111–v777 (.docx and .pdf) of RCL FED COMPLAINT + two "FINAL" versions (one with Digital Signature)
- Framework/Federal Framwork .docx/.pdf — uncle's legal-theory framework
- Discovery/Framwork/FEDERAL RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE- GENERAL PROVISIONS REGARDING DISCOVERY; DUTY OF DISCLOSURE.docx/.pdf
- federal-rules-of-civil-procedure-dec-1-2024_0.pdf — FRCP rulebook
- To Serve subfolder: Civil Cover Sheet Fed.pdf, Federal Summons - ao440.pdf, Lawson_et_al_v_Rubin_et_al__nyedce-17-06404__0311.0.pdf (model case), Pro Se Electronic Document Submission Instructions.pdf, wheretofile.pdf, and _Professioanl Liability Policy - Litman insured as Of Counsel.pdf ← important
Key outgoing counsel correspondence from the July 2025 litigation-trigger window:
- Urgent- Reconciling a ~$15 Million Discrepancy in Financial Reports July 20th 2025.pdf + .docx
- #1 account discrepency .docx
- Formal Notice- Legal Action Initiated – $16.2M+ in Dispute 7:24:25.pdf + .docx
- Subject- "As if he had died" post termination contract July 22nd 2025.pdf + .docx — disability-as-death theory rebuttal
Court-filing templates and the SAC (Second Amended Complaint) packets:
- Chambers_Packet_Cover_Part2.pdf, Exhibit_Index_Part2.pdf, Master_Chambers_Packet_Part2.pdf
- NY PJI (Jury Instruction).docx/.pdf — pattern jury instructions
- Proposed_Consent_Order.docx/.pdf
- rules-rpc-complete.pdf — NY RPC full text
- SAC_Final_Maslow_Compliant.10225.2docx, SAC_Maslow_Compliant.docx, SAC_Revised_Final_Full.pdf, SAC_Revised_Final.docx/.pdf — Second Amended Complaint drafts
- Stipulation_Consent.docx/.pdf
Transaction exports, one-off screenshots, stubs:
- All_Transfers_to_Nath_NGM__2020_2025_.csv — full Nath transfers 2020–2025
- Nath_Payments_2020_to_2025.csv, Nath_Payments_2023_Q2_with_ClientNo.csv/.xlsx, Nath_Payments_2023_Q2.csv
- Formal Response to June 26, 2025 Correspondence, Breach of Agreement, and Demand for Immediate Remediation of Egregious Trust Account Misconduct.docx
- invoices paid account summary .png, King suad 500k payment .png, main account summary.png — screenshot evidence
- LEVER MENU.docx
- Month By Month Payment to Me Breakdown .docx — uncle's reconstructed ledger (do-not-file per Finding #49)
- Three extensionless stubs: Download PDF Report, Download the breakdown report PDF, Download the Report Text — probably empty Dropbox shortcuts
IMG_0371.PNG – IMG_0381.PNG (plus IMG_0378.jpg) — uncle's phone screenshots of the payments actually received. Primary source for the reconstructed monthly ledger.
Motion-for-accounting packet, appears newer than 7/28 (may be Dropbox-synced later):
- 02_Motion.docx, 03_Affirmation_in_Support.docx, 04_Memorandum_of_Law.docx, 06_Certificate_of_Service.docx, 07_RJI_Filing_Checklist.docx
- Bhjkg.docx — stray scratch file
- Complaint_Litman_With_Count_IX.pdf — complaint with the new accounting cause of action (Count IX — new)
- Proposed_Order_Litman_v_Goldberg.pdf
- Nine Exhibit_[A/A-1/A-2/B/C/D/E/F/G]_Cover.docx cover sheets
Historical trust ledger PDFs produced by NGM bookkeeper Grace, segmented into "Parts 1–5":
- Part 1: Trust Ledger May 2019 – Mar 2022 (master)
- Part 2: Trust Ledger Aug 2017 – Aug 2022 (King Faisal split, duplicated)
- Part 3: Trust Ledger May 2023 – Aug 2023
- Part 4: Trust Ledger May 2020 – Apr 2025
- Part 5: Trust Ledger Jan 2020 – Dec 2024 (Al-Ahmad Center for Giftedness & Creativity)
- Client-specific: Trust Ledger - king faisal .pdf, King Faisal University overview.docx
- Two extensionless stubs for "Jul 2020 – Mar 2022" and "May 2019 – Jul 2020"
State action 524343/2025 drafting workspace. Contents are heavily duplicated: RCL COMPLAINT drafts v1, v111, v222, v333, v444, v555, v666, v777, v888, v999 and v2...111 through v2...888 in both .docx and .pdf. Also key one-offs:
- Litman_SAC_Final.docx/.pdf, Litman_SAC_Maslow_Final.pdf
- SAC_Litman_v_Goldberg_Final_Oct3.docx/.pdf, SAC_Litman_v_Goldberg_Full_Oct3.docx, Second_Amended_Complaint_Litman_102251.docx
- Bench_Brief_for_Justice_Maslow.pdf
- 11.28.25 Supplemental Declaration.pdf (+ .1pdf typo variant), UPDATED_Supplemental_Declaration.pdf, UPDATED_Supplemental_Declaration_WITH_MASLOW.pdf
- UPDATED_All_EXHIBIT_AB_Declaration.pdf, UPDATED_Exhibits_PACKET_WITH_MASLOW.pdf
- Notice_of_Cross_Motion.pdf, Table_of_Authorities.pdf, Filing_Cover_Page.pdf, Final_Memo_AI_Certified.pdf, Affirmation_of_Service.pdf
- NYSCEF_Filing_Sequence_Checklist.pdf, NYSCEF_Filing_Procedure_Part2.pdf, Section 202.docx/.pdf (Commercial Division Rules)
- Final_Filing_Bundle.zip, Complete_Filing_Bundle.zip
- Framework/ with 513984_2023_KAROL_PINEDA_v_XING_ZHAO_et_al_SUMMONS___COMPLAINT_1.pdf (model case), Discovery Framwork .docx/.pdf, Filing Procedure.docx/.pdf, Summon for Federal.pdf
- TO SERVE/ with First_Amended_Complaint_state_with_facts.docx, LITMAN VS GOLDBERG COMPLAINT Final.pdf, RJI and File Instructions.docx/.pdf, Summons-Pro-Se 222.pdf, Summons.docx/.pdf, filed state complaint from court, ALL EXHIBITS .pdf
SUMMARY OVERVIEW.pdf + three screenshots dated 7/20/2025 at 12:37/12:39/12:40 PM.
The heaviest primary-source bucket in the package. Two parts:
TRUST LEDGERS/ root (10 files) — RCL-specific trust/billing reports, mostly dated June 2025:
- Billing Journal for RCL June 2024.pdf, Billing Journal for RCL June 2025.pdf
- Client WIP, Billing and Collection Summary_012023.pdf
- Litman 2025 Summary_June-1.pdf + .xlsx
- Payment Allocation by Client Report, for RCL as originating attorney June 2025.pdf
- Receivables by Client report for RCL June 2025.pdf
- Trust Bank Journal June 2025.pdf, Trust Listing for RCL June 2025.pdf
- Trust Register Report June 2025.pdf, Trust Transfer Journal June 2025.pdf
- Outlook-k4uuhqvw.jpeg
TRUST LEDGERS/Jan 2023 Matters (44 files) — a full January 2023 matter bundle:
- 22 Copy of PAD [date] 2023.xlsx files — Payment Allocation Detail workbooks for essentially every business day Dec 16 2022 – Jan 31 2023 (pre-dates the 21-month PAR series starting Oct 2023 — potentially the missing Q3/Q4 2022 + Q1 2023 data per Open Gap #21)
- 32087_70_Application Invoice.pdf, 33101_37_Application Invoice.pdf
- AAA - Gmail - Fwd: January numbers.pdf
- Breakdown for Wire -- 143796.29.docx
- 14 DN* debit-note PDFs (DN314759, DN314775-33044_18U, DN314843, DN314912, DN315029, DN315037, DN315084, DN315086, DN404670-32087_78U, DN404818-33101_09U, DN404835-33101_30U, DN404845-33044_04, DN404905-33101_45U, DN404912-33101_07U, DN405006)
- mime-attachment.eml
AAA - master context.zip (50 MB archive of master context folder)COUNTER ARGUMENT .docx — uncle's counter-argument draftReport Grace Sent - Report_20250626_021254.pdf — Exhibit B source (Grace's 6/26/2025 payment allocation report — the same document at the heart of Finding #50's 8-month suppression)Report_20250626_020523.pdf — companion / earlier version of Grace's reportcourt_filings/ and evidence rootcourt_filings/court_filings/Exhibit_E_Text_Messages_Goldberg.pdfReport_20250626_021254.pdf — already extracted as TRUST_LEDGER_NGM_20250626.pdf and referenced by Finding #50Professional Liability Policy - Litman as Of Counsel — already known (Finding #20)uncle_batch_2026-04-07/uncle_batch_2026-04-07/ has parallel cutsMonth By Month Payment to Me Breakdown .pdf / .docx — uncle's memory-reconstructed monthly ledger. Primary source for Finding #49's do-not-file figure. Not previously archived as a standalone file.PAD [date] 2023.xlsx files (Dec 16 2022 – Jan 31 2023) — Payment Allocation Detail workbooks pre-dating the Oct 2023 PAR series. Likely helps close Open Gap #21 (missing Jul/Aug/Sep 2023 + Q3 2023 PAR data) — or proves PAD existed contemporaneously as a different format.Billing Journal for RCL June 2024.pdf — RCL billing journal for June 2024, specifically — potential damages anchor mid-window.All_Transfers_to_Nath_NGM__2020_2025_.csv — full 5-year transfer export. Directly queryable vs. BOA account 003926278751 (Finding #57).Nath_Payments_2023_Q2_with_ClientNo.csv/.xlsx — Q2 2023 payments with client number column. Critical for validating the client-renumbering scheme (Finding #27).Litman 2025 Summary_June.xlsx — RCL summary spreadsheet form.COUNTER ARGUMENT .docx — uncle's rebuttal working draft.SUMMARY OVERVIEW.pdf + 3 screenshots (7/20/2025 12:37–12:40) — uncle's 1-page-overview source-of-truth as of 7/20.Report_20250626_020523.pdf — sibling report to Grace's 021254 report, 7 minutes earlier, possibly different parameters. Not previously noted.30011517220031SCIV.PDF — unidentified SCIV filing, needs opening.Client & Owner Numbers.xlsx — client number crosswalk workbook, directly on point for the renumbering scheme evidence.NGM_Litman_Workup (Lawyers Summary) .xlsx — lawyer-facing workup spreadsheet.mime-attachment.eml in Jan 2023 Matters — one raw email for content extraction.Ranked by evidentiary value against current case theory:
| # | File | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | TRUST LEDGERS/Jan 2023 Matters/Copy of PAD [22 daily files].xlsx |
Potentially closes Open Gap #21 (pre-Oct 2023 PAR data). First evidence that NGM kept daily PAD workbooks before the monthly-report format. Validate against the 21-month time-series (Finding #66). |
| 2 | TRUST LEDGERS/Payment Allocation by Client Report, for RCL as originating attorney June 2025.pdf |
Exactly the document type suppressed for 8 months in Finding #50. This is the June 2025 sibling of the July 2025 PAR. |
| 3 | TRUST LEDGERS/Trust Bank Journal June 2025.pdf + Trust Transfer Journal June 2025.pdf |
Direct trust-account activity ledger for the month immediately before litigation trigger. Pair with BOA 003926278751 (Finding #57). |
| 4 | TRUST LEDGERS/Billing Journal for RCL June 2024.pdf |
Adds a mid-window damages data point between the 22/24-month NGM productions and validates monthly pattern. |
| 5 | Report Grace Sent - Report_20250626_021254.pdf + Report_20250626_020523.pdf |
Grace-authored companion reports; the 020523 version is new (7 minutes earlier). Compare to detect parameter changes / concealed fields. |
| 6 | MISC/All_Transfers_to_Nath_NGM__2020_2025_.csv |
5-year full transfer export. Enables SQL-style reconciliation against $9.89M KFU unallocated (Finding #51). |
| 7 | MISC/Nath_Payments_2023_Q2_with_ClientNo.csv/.xlsx |
Client-number column tests the renumbering scheme (Finding #27) directly. |
| 8 | EXHBITS/Context/Client & Owner Numbers.xlsx |
NGM's own client-number crosswalk. Core evidence for Finding #27 + Finding #52 double-overlay. |
| 9 | EXHBITS/Context/SUS LARGE TRANSACTIONS .pdf |
Uncle-curated list of suspect transactions — read directly into Anomalous Transactions catalog. |
| 10 | EXHBITS/Context/maybe fradu payment IMG_0429.pdf |
Flagged fraud-indicator screenshot uncle set aside. Needs triage. |
| 11 | Lawyer Letters/Urgent- Reconciling a ~$15 Million Discrepancy 7/20/2025.pdf + Formal Notice- Legal Action Initiated – $16.2M+ in Dispute 7:24:25.pdf |
The litigation-trigger letters. These are the drafts behind the $16.2M accounting gap finding (Finding #19) and establish the July 24 formal litigation notice — one day before the 7/28 package date, 6 days before the July 18 email elimination. Pre-dates all later spoliation. |
| 12 | Lawyer Letters/Subject- "As if he had died" post termination contract July 22nd 2025.pdf |
Uncle's direct rebuttal of disability=death defense. |
| 13 | Context July 19th 2025/NGM_Litman_Workup (Lawyers Summary) .xlsx |
Uncle's lawyer-facing workup — probable source for the original damages numbers. |
| 14 | Context July 19th 2025/Month By Month Payment to Me Breakdown .pdf |
Primary source for Finding #49 (do-not-file but load-bearing for understanding uncle's original narrative). |
| 15 | Context July 19th 2025/Formal Response to June 26, 2025 Correspondence…Trust Account Misconduct.pdf |
Uncle's formal trust-misconduct response letter — direct anchor for NY/VA/DC Rule 1.15 theory (Finding #67/#68). |
| 16 | TRUST LEDGERS/Jan 2023 Matters/DN404670-32087_78U.pdf through DN405006.pdf (14 debit notes) |
First granular debit-note PDFs in corpus. Sample Jan 2023 KFU (33101) and Kuwait University (33044) — test against "2,457 KFU dockets without invoice" (Finding #63). |
| 17 | TRUST LEDGERS/Jan 2023 Matters/AAA - Gmail - Fwd: January numbers.pdf |
Email forwarding "January numbers" (parallels Exhibit P) — candidate for $1.4M wire context (Exhibit J). |
| 18 | All invoices on files you are introducing - All dates with AR/All invoices…All dates.csv + All Payments Received….xlsx |
Machine-readable receivables + payments — directly rebuilds Exhibit D as a queryable dataset. |
| 19 | COUNTER ARGUMENT .docx (root) |
Uncle's own rebuttal of Goldberg's defenses. Captures theories that never made it into the filed complaint — use to mine for alternative arguments. |
| 20 | Federal Complaint/To Serve/Lawson_et_al_v_Rubin_et_al__nyedce-17-06404__0311.0.pdf |
The EDNY model case uncle used for his federal complaint framework — reveals his theory-of-the-case analogy. |
RCL COMPLAINT v2...888.pdf / RCL COMPLAINT v999.pdf.Download PDF Report, etc.) and 2 extensionless OG Trust Ledger stubs are likely empty — verify and remove or reconstruct.