Discovery Production

Litman v. Goldberg — Index No. 524343/2025 — NY Sup. Ct., Kings County
Judge: Hon. Brian L. Gotlieb, J.S.C. — Producing Party: Plaintiff Richard C. Litman — Production Date: April 14, 2026
280,029
Total Documents
3,130
Non-Email Documents
276,899
Email Communications
13,830
Document Pages (Est.)
90,676
Emails with Attachments
LITMAN000001 – LITMAN278898
Bates Range

Production Format & Loading Instructions

This production contains industry-standard Concordance DAT load files compatible with Relativity, Concordance, Nuix, DISCO, and any EDRM-compliant review platform.

Load files:
• DATA/LITMAN_DOCUMENT_PRODUCTION.dat — 3,130 non-email documents
• DATA/LITMAN_EMAIL_PRODUCTION.dat — 276,899 email communications
• DATA/*.opt — Opticon image cross-reference files

DAT Format: Text qualifier: \xFE (thorn) • Field separator: \x14 (ASCII 20) • Encoding: UTF-8
Confidentiality: CONFIDENTIAL — ATTORNEY EYES ONLY

Overview
Documents (3,130)
Emails (276,899)
Analytics

Document Categories

17 Categories
Category Documents Pages (Est.) Bates Range Description
PATENTS 27 360 LITMAN000001 — LITMAN000360 Patent front pages and annotated patents
POA_DOCUMENTS 60 153 LITMAN000361 — LITMAN000513 Powers of Attorney — Goldberg/Lafave signatures
USPTO_FILING_DOCS 191 1,786 LITMAN000514 — LITMAN002299 Filing receipts, NOAs, office actions from USPTO IFW
ASSIGNMENT_DOCS 20 70 LITMAN002300 — LITMAN002369 Assignment documents — Goldberg as submitter
WEBSITE_EVIDENCE 183 183 LITMAN002370 — LITMAN002552 Website screenshots showing Litman's name
COURT_FILINGS 69 565 LITMAN002553 — LITMAN003117 Court filings from NYSCEF and federal case
AAA_LAWSUIT_PACKAGE 93 2,284 LITMAN003118 — LITMAN005401 Federal complaint exhibits A-R, trust ledgers, workup
FINANCIAL_DOCUMENTS 25 211 LITMAN005402 — LITMAN005612 Financial evidence — trust accounts, payment records, workup
ICLOUD_PHOTOS 291 291 LITMAN005613 — LITMAN005903 iCloud photos — text messages, emails, patent pages
EMAIL_FILES 535 5,295 LITMAN005904 — LITMAN011198 Individual email files (.eml, .emlx) from various sources
GMAIL_ATTACHMENTS 7 54 LITMAN011199 — LITMAN011252 Downloaded Gmail attachments — financial, legal, correspondence
DOCUMENT_PHOTOS 1,536 1,536 LITMAN011253 — LITMAN012788 Document photos — OCR'd evidence from uncle's phone
IMESSAGE_ATTACHMENTS 35 381 LITMAN012789 — LITMAN013169 iMessage attachments — discovery, financial, legal filings
REPUBLICATION_EVIDENCE 10 163 LITMAN013170 — LITMAN013332 Republication evidence — third-party patent databases showing Litman
EVIDENCE_ROOT 17 300 LITMAN013333 — LITMAN013632 Root-level evidence files — arbitration filings, declarations, trust ledgers
PREPARED_EXHIBITS 12 176 LITMAN013633 — LITMAN013808 Labeled exhibits prepared for production
ANALYSIS_PRODUCTS 19 22 LITMAN013809 — LITMAN013830 Analysis outputs — CSVs, memos, exhibits

Production Notes

Important
  1. Public Records: Many USPTO documents (patent front pages, filing receipts, NOAs) are public records. They are produced here for convenience and to demonstrate the specific name-use pattern.
  2. Privilege: Documents prepared in anticipation of litigation, attorney work-product, and attorney-client communications have been withheld. A privilege log will be provided separately if requested per CPLR 3122(b).
  3. Rolling Production: This production is made on a rolling basis. Plaintiff reserves the right to supplement.
  4. Financial Records: Plaintiff's damages analysis is derived from Defendant's own financial spreadsheets produced by Defendant on February 20, 2026.
  5. Email Communications: All 276,899 emails are produced with full metadata in DAT format. Native .msg files are available in the NATIVES directory.
  6. Verification: All documents include MD5 hash verification for integrity confirmation.
3,130 documents
Bates # Type File Name Description Category Size Pages Hash
Showing sample

Showing first 5,000 of 276,899 emails. Full dataset available in DAT load file.

Bates # Date From To Subject Attach Source

Top Email Senders

15 senders
SenderCount
mlong@nathlaw.com57,352
jgoldberg@nathlaw.com6,159
nytdirect@nytimes.com5,526
quarantine@messaging.microsoft.com5,202
subscriptioncenter@subscriptions.uspto.gov5,082
noreply@editme.com4,634
jobalerts-noreply@linkedin.com3,538
iptl@ksu.edu.sa3,527
sleon@nathlaw.com3,309
hkline@nathlaw.com2,678
rlitman@nathlaw.com2,400
lawpracticecle@lawpracticecle.com1,978
store-news@amazon.com1,907
newsreview@sustg.org1,904
messages-noreply@linkedin.com1,803

Emails by Year

16 years
YearCount
20171
201856
201910,176
202042,440
202131,768
202229,041
202344,997
202457,819
202555,877
20264,670
21611
22592
24941
26381
27682
29303

Litman v. Goldberg — Index No. 524343/2025 — NY Sup. Ct., Kings County
Production Date: April 14, 2026 — Producing Party: Plaintiff Richard C. Litman
CONFIDENTIAL — ATTORNEY EYES ONLY